Straight Sets Simon

The only bias was the love between Carey and Rance.

His ability to quickly get the ball on to his foot and hit a target is first-class.

They've got good depth then?

I've changed my mind, Harmes needs to stay in.

Frost out is a fair call.

The pre-game service was all class, very proud of how Melbourne and Richmond have done this the past two years. Sadly, I wasn't surprised to hear Channel Seven cut short the Last Post to go to an ad, sums them up perfectly.

Agreed, Viney did it well considering the heat of the moment.

When that happened a Richmond supporter near me was going off his head because it wasn't paid a free kick. As soon as the replay showed Morris staged everyone turned and laughed at the supporter, in fairness he took it well.

Oliver must come back in for Brayshaw, not sure about other changes. Petracca for Harmes? Harmes would be very unlucky.

Brayshaw just doesn't look right at the moment.

Richmond versus Port Adelaide next week will be so bad that it will be hard to look away.

This year is already proving to be extremely even. There will be a log jam from about 5th to 16th where any number of teams can make the top eight. It will probably come down to a game or two and percentage.

Viney will not even get cited.

I was at the game, not sure if you were or not but I think perceptions can be very different when compared to watching on TV.

His field kicking wasn't great and he looked to crack the sads a few times.

6 . Gawn 5. Viney 4. Tyson 3. Vince 2. Garlett 1. McDonald

I know, I just really don't rate Richmond and I wanted the percentage boost!

You're a better man than I am.

A lot of sloppy kicks, missed tackles and just general poor skills that could have been avoided if the players were a bit sharper. I'm ecstatic we won, but Richmond really were terrible and they only got as close as they did because we allowed them to. Who was supposed to be on Edwards by the way?

Spot on.

He very much took the moral high ground regarding the Goodes booing situation. That's fine, it's his view but essentially to be so high and mighty over one issue then and to condone physical violence is pathetic.

Take a bow, but please never kick across the face of goal.

Andrew Wu from Fairfax with the most disgusting tweet regarding Watts getting punched.

Skill errors, bad decisions, laziness and umpiring.

How many weeks? Dog act.