Satyriconhome

That was my first conversation, approached at training, rock and a hard place, says and does too much is then interfering

This is Wilson, she has form, half of it is unsubstantiated rumour, as you can see, as per norm, she doesn't name names Normal business doesn't get the outgoing CEO to tick off the incoming

This is Caroline Wilson I have, he is approachable at functions etc, it's just supporters don't approach, always seems to have the best intentions for the Club

1. I don't rate Gaff like others do 2, MFC footy dept may rate him fine 3. I know West Coast supporters who were shocked/surprised with his B&F win 4. Where has this stellar form been for last 2 years 5. We have some exploding posters on here 6. Don't give a flying what the Keyboard Warriors on here think about me There you go paraphrase and misrepresent away

I am not worried, gee paraphrasing, misrepresentation, runs the whole gamut of trying to point score Forgot this was a schoolyard for 'grownups' "Superstars" regularly win B&F my point to Picket, he won once, in a victory that was a shock to West Coast supporters I know, some think he is brilliant, others have the same opinion as me, an accumulator and nothing else, in comparison may I say nobody was surprised when Clarry won MFC B&F If we select Gaff, cool, can then sit back and watch the angst if he doesn't chase defensively or go when it is his turn I am answering like for like, the only language some on here understand, if there is a discussion/debate then fair enough, but hey contrary opinion to the group think.......only derision

Gaff has had games like last Friday night, agree he has been showing more inside this year, but when the heat was on against an aggressive inside midfield, he went missing

Wrong why, I explained my answer, rather than take potshots like others Why apologise, his B&F shocked hardcore West Coast supporters, because I know a few What's wrong? can't handle a different opinion, you didn't answer my post, but I expect little else Interesting that lesser mortals leave this site, as if they dare to be contrary, they get abuse/derision/etc etc Hey faux tough guy, your normal running in from behind to king hit, without actually contributing to the topic, classy It is an opinion of a particular player, if you don't agree and have a contrary view, how about expressing why, or is it just the "oh my he is a free agent, let's get him'

Misrepresenting what I said to make a point I think Gaff is overrated Think Stretch has the tools to be developed into a player who can fill the role everybody thinks Gaff is made for

Of course we are interested, he is a free agent, lot of water under the bridge yet though, no issue with the club if they bring him in, I just don't rate him as a player, everybody has a different opinion, each week Goody picks a side, not everybody likes who he picks I just don't understand the absolute hysteria surrounding him, he may be a reasonable player, but he is no superstar

He is a free agent, so most clubs will have a look It is rumoured we are interested My opinion, everybody is allowed an opinion, unless of course you subscribe to the group speak, opinions are neither right or wrong Always thought of him as an accumulator, rather than a ball winner, goes missing when the heat is on more often that not, ie the Sydney game last weekend If we sign him, means the club rate him, so will support him as a MFC player, there are players on our list at the moment that I have opinions about that are different to others, again it doesn't mean one is wrong and the other right Unfortunately some on here can't debate, they just deride

A superstar wins B&F consistently and wins the Brownlow, my answer to Picket, his win in 2015 surprised everybody, and that was a couple of years ago, he is an accumulator, and he is not fast, where this impression comes from I have no idea Doesn't matter about my opinion, it is my opinion, so it is not irrelevant Stretch is being developed, it may work, it may not

My response was to @picket fence who called him a superstar, when he won in 2015, even West Coast supporters were surprised Every year on here a player gets turned into the second coming because supposedly he is interested in coming to Melbourne My opinion is Gaff is an accumulator, and his defence is questionable prefer to develop Stretch The Sydney game showed the 'real' Gaff, the heat was on and he went missing, happened in the past Now if it was Shuey, would be over there helping him pack

Why is it unfounded, is yours because I don't agree with it The point I continually raise on here, mob rules, if you don't agree YOU ARE WRONG

So he is going to play halfback? Lewis and Vince don't rotate through there much any more I have never been a fan of Gaff, if the footy dept are and get him, fine, I will have no issue

What does he actually bring, we are averaging a tick under 100 points a game lately so moving the ball isn't the issue everybody seems to think it is

The whole team is playing well, at the weekend against Sydney, he went missing again when the heat was on, my knock on him He is an accumulator, would prefer to keep developing Stretch Media, I pay no attention to the media, do you?

So he has gone backwards, my point, he lacks consistency, when it gets hot he disappears He is an outside accumulator Everybody is entitled to an opinion, personally to paraphrase Talking Footy 'overrated' for me

He hasn't managed a West Coast B&F or a high finish at the Brownlow, so superstar may be a slight overreach on your part Those against Gaff coming to Melbourne are not being reticent, expressing opinion openly

I contributed to the topic, Wiseblood made a smartarse comment, I had had enough of that, I got a holiday, move on There seems to be rules for some and not others on here, something I have expressed to the mods as well Back on topic and in answer to the above Gaff hope not, downhill skier, as evidenced by him going missing when it was hot against Sydney Wallis hope not, we have enough of his type Langdon hope not, needs a consistent season or two But I don't do the recruiting and if any of the above happens will support

Please please please please the same for me, a badge of honour, also means no more of your puerile humorous retorts to my posts

Actually you are just being a troll, anything to add on the topic? At the moment I would say, in my opinion, the only 2 I would say are 'going' would be JKH and Pedersen

It's an opinion, woe betide anybody that tries to do the same to some of you wonderful experts, hence the hypocrisy comment I don't agree with his opinion on Brayshaw, but wouldn't call him a troll, as he quoted an opinion and didn't launch an attack on a poster Notice the difference, probably not I normally get trolled whether I give an opinion or not, notice the difference, probably not

Ah the hypocrisy in full flight @buck_nekkid Yes Big Demon has a different opinion, and out come the troll posts Thought this was a public board and posters could post what they like Yeah right I don't agree with Big Demon but he is entitled to his opinion. Isn't he?

There is block of land adjacent to Goschs, that can be redeveloped, was mentioned a couple of months ago Pert is a good operator

Why would he lure 2 players nobody has heard of, unless of course you mean Magner and Georgiou Seems your post went wrong Kent, like other players before him, just needs a clear run at it, if he, or his manager thinks it would be better at another club so be it