BrownlowBruce

u should know by now bruce is the villain every week... find one incident per game.... where he did bad.... it haunts him for the week... Yze prolific not wasteful second efforts were great.... he dooin wat everyone of his critics have asked of him ... give him some credit.. Warnock- has no future. Bate- its about time.

Hey jaded...... u can win the flag from 7th or 8th u cant win a flag from 14th or 13th

tarrant no.. wat about power? re think ur opinion..... miller is playin great football and i belive the future of MFC may lie within him.... we cant afford to trade him... he has proven himself this season and he has worked hard to be more consistant.... Rhyce prissmall interesting..... i went to school with both him and his brother.. and know brent quite well..... it is said he is suppose to be better than his older brother.... but i cant see him maturing and adapting as quick to AFL football like brent has...... brent has a better size about him now ... and did when he was younger too. we need some more defenders... not midfeilders...

funny noone notices the game plan we we actually win.... soon as u lose everyone asks wat the game plan is? obviously if we dont win.... the game plan didnt work.... was not executed by the players well enough.... or maybe our game plan doesnt suit our team....... when we actually win maybe our game plan will be more evident

Has anyone else noticed... despite losin all our games.... melbourne have still had their chances in all if not most games they have played.... watchin sydneys game again yesterday i realised although we were still down by 4 goals or more at most stages.... melb seemed to dominate the game and pressure the swans..... now if it wasnt for some f.ed decisions like nick davis holding the ball/throw which the umpire actually gave him a free kick in front of goal, this was around the same time when barry hall was not payed holding the ball for claiming a mark he had cleary not marked..... anyway my point is... with the right avenues to goal i still feel melbourne is a great chance this year..... we dominated the swans for atleast 1/2 the game..... we were a chance against the hawks in the last 10 mins......we competed with freo for 3 quarters just got killed in the second i think melbourne has really done well ... to compete with the injuries and the state of of mind they have with 0 wins.... avenue to goal is the only thing that can save us tho.... i say rush neitz and robbo back ASAP ..... with abit of luck we could turn this season from hell right around....

looks like adem yze will have to better fletchers goal... which won goal of the week over his miracle banana... results 40% to yzes 34%

perhaps sautner

adam goodes has been cited for his dog act drawing 225 demerit points and a two-match sanction. becuase of an existing five-year good record b reduces the penalty by 25 per cent to 168.75 An early plea reduces by 25 per cent to 126.56 demerit points and a one-match sanction. that stuffs his consecutive games and his bronnlow chances... bet he gets off.. tho

leading miller ,bruce, moloney BELL i dont know where he really fits.. in award for most improved hands down.... he has come a long way... im lookin foward to seeing if he can become our best small defender even by the end of the year.... dont think his disposal is the best of our club or near that tho and why is that... Do u think bell is leadin our best and fairest also do u DD?

funny, the silence from u last week..

if bell is leadin out best and fairest i will buy u ur membership next year lord travis hes been improved greatly ... last year he was a talentless hack.... this year.... talented hack.... great too see him approve so much.... but still a class below....

would we prefer a des headland culture? punch on after the game?

despite all ur words of wisdom rhino .... fact is he kicked 55 goals last year as a small forward... the second best of his career..... pretty good for a fat man. doubt he will come back to melbourne.... but still a great player..

..i dont know about u jaded... but some of us have not lost hope.... this is the biggest game of the year atm for MFC..... i would risk neitz .... if he does have an injury re occurance the odds are he will be back by next year anyway..... melb must win this game... interstate team vs melb at the G this is our biggest chance....... melb need to start winning.... being underdogs suits us.... we are known chokers .... we win a game or too with injuries who knows we could storm into the 8 come round 22 with a fit side and who knows wat is to come..... OUT bate injured/omitted, Brown, Garland, Cj IN Neitz, Green, Buckley, Newton

once again jaded u fail to give any respect to cameron bruce.... u are the most biest supporter i have met u defend bell week in week out.... yes he trys hard... but i hate to say it he does alot of silly things.... godfrey played well..... Bruce best easily spoilt chased tackled marked goaled and ran alll game..... bruce not interested ? get ur eyes checked

Why not ? we beat them last year.... scg is small we are suppose to be a fit side this year.... 4 big qrt efforts.... Yze and davey on fire last week .... sydney have no match up for him and davey in their backline.... this is their chance to dominate again and prove a point... miller and dunn leadin well... lets get numbers back in the backline (white ) and co... rivers back in .... provide assistance to carrol.... Bruce on goodes ... if bruce is put in the backline i will cry...bruce kicked some tellin goals last year it will be great if he can do it again... it would be great if he can shut down the browlow medalist and peform himself... and who knows wat to expect from the 2 newbies.... good luck to them both and CMON DEES

no the game where he fell into the back and gave away a certain goal in the dying stages of a cruical game.... poor effort.... and he shouldnt be playin if he has shoulder problems anyway..... and he is crap with or without shoulder problems

because his lazy undisipline football may well have costed us the game vs hawthorn...... goood enough reason for me..... when the going gets tough the tough get going... goodbye wheatley....

i dunno about Riewolt been in there so high ..... i think u could slip him down to 9 and i would put simon black over chad cornes

agree with u totally.... apart from bell not most consistent but trying his hardest which is good.

19 touches to Adem yze in round 1 wasnt relevant, when u were gettin stuck into him..... he has plenty to kick too... but the fact is he cant kick... and he has to work on in.... i dont think we are writing him off.... but just sayin he is basically crap at the moment.... his clanger and critical error count is as high as anyone on the team.... maybe he needa melb to win to be abit more confident... give him a few more.... no improvment ... and i will write him off for this year. not for the future

i think yze magic has a valid point... about the umpires.... maybe melbourne has not been spoken well enough about the rule changes... and the umpires foucs on other rules... according to all the media players and coaches and other football faces are told about the new rules and even given a DVD on the in the back rule.... now has anyone got a stat for Free kicks resulting in goals For and against melb.... i think u will find there is a big big difference.... one that springs to mind..... round 1. holding the ball rule? worst umpired match i have even seen... st kilda kicked about 3 goals from that alone... st kilda couldnt kick their first goal until they were give a free kick also. bad umpiring? or bad coaching? or lazy/careless players?

not even the coach?

Get on AFL.com. and vote for Yze goal of the round... he has some competition this week with fletcher and hansen...

wat a load of CRAP....... if it wasnt for STUPID supporters ..... who .... put the heat on him.... he would have never asked to be dropped..... now i know the facts.... i do read.... and i dont think an AFL player would asked to be dropped 2 games into a season because he feels he needs be especially a player of his standard........ CLEARLY a peer pressure type effect was put on him..... and to think it was all based on his decision would be utter garbage..... Well done Yze..... ... how long to they get on ur back again tho?