
-
NON-MFC: Finals Week 01
Freo a chance to sack JL?
-
CASEY: Semi Final vs Frankston
Wow this is poor from 15? AFL listed players.
-
NON-MFC: Finals Week 01
The standard of umpiring combined with the complete lack of consistency in the application of virtually any rules is one of the biggest issues in the game. At times it’s unwatchable.
-
Who Will Be Our Next Coach?
I think it’s time we start calling him the almighty El Jefe
-
Who Will Be Our Next Coach?
i Agree, but I think it’s just a mature acknowledgement from the club this isn’t just a footy coaching role, the entire club needs realignment and repair and the person to do that is going to need experience
-
Who Will Be Our Next Coach?
I think 3 years is the sweet spot regardless of who we select. it gives us a good look at them, but a bit of a get out option if it's a total disaster. I don't think the first contract of a coaching stint should ever be more than that, and i'd even argue it shouldn't be full stop. We've seen amazing coaches like Malthouse, Clarkson and so on go to clubs and struggle, so it feels like too big a gamble to treat coaching contracts the way we do players.
-
Who Will Be Our Next Coach?
Hense the long, thorough process we're currently going through. Whoever we choose will be properly vetted and recommended by the panel, we can't really do much more
-
Who Will Be Our Next Coach?
you might well be right, but could you imagine if we did go for an assistant over someone like Nathan Buckley and they ended but being another Mark Neeld? getting these decisions long can set the club back 5-10 years
-
Hypocritical Collingwood supporters calling out booing of Quaynor
That'll do it! thanks mate.
-
Hypocritical Collingwood supporters calling out booing of Quaynor
What was the deal with Maynard and Keays post game? did anyone see what happened there?
-
Hypocritical Collingwood supporters calling out booing of Quaynor
it really is something to out-feral Collingwood supporters.
-
Trade Targets
I think if we were to consider a trade to the Hawks of Petracca, someone like Cam McKenzie being included in a deal with draft pick(s) would be appealing potentially. I think he's someone who would add to our young core coming through and potentially give us some value. The draft pool this year is pretty heavily compromised and i suspect with Tassie coming on board we're a little while away from a totally clear draft like what we had last year so we may have to get a little more creative to add to our talent pool. It's why the idea of us doing a Richmond and trading everyone out for bulk draft picks is silly, the whole plan is based on the idea there is talent available to us within that pathway
-
Who Will Be Our Next Coach?
For sure, lets go a highly touted Collingwood assistant! we nailed that last time haha
-
Who Will Be Our Next Coach?
I think the appeal of Buckley is the potential Paul Roos impact of changing the culture of the entire organisation, our challenge doesn't just involve on field and it's silly to suggest it does. We've had rolling drama for a few years, what appears from the outside to be slipping standards on and of the field and off field issues to key players as well have behavioral/attitude ones. The reason Bucks appeals to me more than say Skipworth is that any edge Skipworth might have purely in terms of coaching is likely significantly outweighed by the benefits of Buckley in terms of raising the standards across the board and coming in with an aura that demands immediate respect and credibility. This impacts sponsors, players considering the MFC, players undecided about staying at the club, the caliber of support staff we might bring in, there is a whole list of benefits someone like Nathan Buckley brings that go way beyond coaching. So even if we thought Skipworth was a slightly better coach, i think there is still a very obvious reason Buckley is the run away favourite for the role.
-
Hypocritical Collingwood supporters calling out booing of Quaynor
Additionally i am really looking forward to the mental gymnastics the AFL does this week to justify not suspending Jordan De Goey for an action that's been suspended consistently every other time it's happened.