What

Paul Roos can not coach for the modern game Id let Goodwin take over and Roos can finish his contract as director of coaching or whatever Juat hope Goodwin has an attacking flair to his own gameplan

Luumumba isn't a midfielder even if hes playing there for us. Should be at half back, Cross is old and just a battler, Vince is a good B grader, Tyson is carrying something, Vandenberg is a 7 gamer, Salem is playing half back,Brayshaw is a rookie We dont have any star midfielders and still bad depth

Dogs have 13 players with 50 games or less experience. And some people here were using the excuse of inexperience for us in the last 3 weeks What a [censored] poor excuse it is

Of course We still have by far the worst midfield in the league

Dogs midfield just plays smart footy that all other clubs play. besides Melbourne, Why are our players so pathetically dumb?

We will beat the Doggies if Hogan and Viney are back

Would like to see him stay in and play vs the Doggies. He and Stretch really got thrown to the wolves the last 2 weeks vs two powerhouse teams chock full of big bodied experienced players Terrible effort by the selectors

Must get a blue chip midfielder or two art seasons end... maybe a godfather offer to someone like Shiel or Trealoar, we have to try something.. anything... It simply must happen , no excuses Add a blue chip ready made gun to the midfield plus Petracca coming in 2016 and we will be on the way

Still don;t think Jetta will be ready Pray to the heavens that Jesse and Viney will be ready

The players we have out are just about the ones we can least afford to lose after T Mac, Jonesy and Hogan (who missed today anywa) Jetta, Kent, Frost, Viney... all of them are warriors and hard as hell and are just so crucial. If we had our best 22 or close to it we could compete just about every week.... but as has been noted many times once we lose 5, 6, 7 guys from our best 22 we have no choice but to replace them with VFL level players cos thats all we have as back up

Take your pick Melbourne? Carlton? Suns? Two more possible candidates tomorrow depending on what the Tigers and Lions do

I really hope Roos negative boring game plan doesn't rub off on Goodwin

If Goodwin doesnt turn out to be a great coach we are stuffed

how did ANB go today?

Hes a terrible, terrible footballer How he conned the club into a big contract just blows my mind The Pies couldn't have cared less when he left them

Carlton are lucky that wasnt over 100 points

Still puts him ahead of Watts and Dawes who are woeful nearly every week

Think you'll find I said he was good last season too. Cheers

GWS are frightening. Not only do they have all that talent but they are reaching their potential comfortably Complete opposite to the MFC

Maybe we should have bought him in as president after all

I never understood why he was dropped toward the end of last year, he was having a fine season up forward on a team with no midfield and barely any inside 50 entries and none of those entries of any quality. He should have played every game this season, he is better than Watts and Dawes combined. He was one of our top players today vs the hawks and the sad thing is he was only in the team due to a late change. Kicks goals, can take a contested grab, is athletic and can relief ruck. He will complement Hogan well. Paul Roos needs to wake up and start picking the best teams each week, not just the best names on paper.

If he had stayed at Melbourne he would have turned out average at best Was a great career decision by him

GWS have more spirit and fabric than our 150 year old club Makes me sick

Damn shame To think we could have gotten pick 7 for that spud makes me so angry

And he has had two offseason periods to get rid of then Yet they still remain Roos has been garbage