Cranky Franky

Whoever wrote this is an fool & I don't know why some people get their kicks out of humiliating past players. Also you can't spell. Shanahan was a top notch full back & had a great first year but then played one year too many. Holland has been a very handy footballer. Norrish was a handy player who won a B&F at Freo. Charles was a brilliant talent but was hampered by injuries & a poor attitude. Vardy was outstanding when fit. Prymke held down CHB for 2 years before being injured. Doyle & Irving were both reasonable players & Newton had his career wrecked by injury. Fair dinkum do you actually ever go to a game because you really have no idea.

Well its early days of course but Isaac is having injury after injury after injury while Joe Anderson lines up for his third game tomorrow. Time will tell.

What the hell are our medical staff up to !!!!! The Swans have managed to nurse their list so that they played in 2 grand finals without any injuries. Mclean, Moloney, Sylvia and Wheatley have been carrying soft tissue injuries every friggin year. Whats going on !!!!!

I didn't think Melbourne supporters would be so conservative. No wonder opposition supporters make jokes about Range Rovers, port & cigars & Falls Creek in July

Yes were a bit like the old Public Service. You promote the person who has been there the longest regardless of ability I actually thought merit might be a consideration. We are one of the few clubs with the 10 year rule. Most clubs take into account what someone puts in to a club not just how long they've been there.

The Club usually gives life membership after 10 years. Nicho picked it up this year & I know that in the past some players have got it after doing little more than hanging about for 10 years. I reckon we ought to give it to the following players: Laurie Fowler - he was an absolute champion for us 140 games - played for Victoria & 3 B&F's. Carl Ditterich - one of the toughest & most inspirational players to pull on the guernsey 82 games, Captain Coach & a B&F winner. Max Walker - terrific bloke, honest, gutsy ruckman 85 games & would have played 100 games+ if he had not concentrated on his cricket full time.

A lot of supporters (as well as players) live in Fantasy Land when it comes to the last year(s) of their favourite players. Most careers just limp along & fade out. Age & injuries respect nobody. Look at Carey, Lockett, Modra, Ablett - all should have retired well before they did. Bizzell was a great player now he is only a spare parts man. Anyone who thinks he is going to recapture his form of a few years ago is deluded.

Trouble with Scott is that he got into the habit of not taking the first option. He would get the ball then instead of doing the obvious thing ie quick kick or handball he would try & take on the opposition then if he beat his man he would look around & try & try & take on another man invariabaly he would just get tackled or turn the ball over.

Just goes to show that a lot of people that do this must spend all of 30 seconds on their research. Alves & Hardeman are out for obvious reasons. Laurie Fowler is a walk up start - he was not only a back pocket but a very good on baller & Alan Johnson could play in several positions. Also Glen Lovett is in for mine - one of the most underatted players of the era - never played a bad game & rarely beaten plus could play in many positions. The trouble with Danny Hughes at full back is that he struggled with anyone who had some pace - maybe Shanahan would be a better bet.

Exactly none. But I think that on achievements so far Joe's credentials are a mile ahead of Isack's. Of course I could be completely wrong on this matter. I would love to see both players do well although if Joe does well it will always bug me that he went to a low life team like Carlton.

I was really hoping we would draft Joe Anderson & was very surprised when we got Weetra @ 62. Carlton then got Anderson @ 67. Weetra has potential but has only played at u 19 level in SA. Anderson has been playing in the firsts against men since he was 16. At 17 he won the Darwin B&F, was a very good player in the team's Premiership side & captained the NT under 18 side. He was rated by commentators to be one of the best young players to come out of the NT for a while. His grandfather Jimmy Anderson was an NT legend & one of the best ever players to pull on a pair of boots. I just thought that Joe was a mile ahead of Isack in terms of ability & potential. Just hope this isn't another Joel Campbell or Mark Berts effort.