Jump to content

Random Task

Life Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Random Task

  1. Random Task replied to dazzledavey36's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    Change it to West Coast giving back their future 2nd and it might be more reasonable.
  2. Random Task replied to dazzledavey36's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    I'm not advocating for extra assistance to North but nearly beating 2 very average teams isn't a convincing counter-argument for those that are. Eagles won a flag only 5 years ago. No chance they receive draft assistance.
  3. Ultimately it comes down to contract price, length and some unknown formula the afl uses that factors in age and god knows what else. Since those are secret, they can disguise draft assistance with a first round compensation pick quite easily. I will say that Frawley had played nearly twice the amount of games and earned himself an AA jacket. McKay is not the same quality and hard to see a team spending upwards of 800k per year on him.
  4. He's kicking was much improved in this game. Strikes me as someone that works hard at his footy. Surely we'll pick him up late or as a rookie.
  5. I don't mind the idea but we have JvR now who is similar in that they're both slightly undersized, but have good athleticism and can crash a pack. The wild rumour of Oscar Allen that @adonski referenced would be perfect. Otherwise Naughton or a King twin are the established forwards I would go hard it. Wouldn't mind Todd Marshall either. Can't imagine any of them being available though.
  6. Random Task replied to Random Task's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    Gentle reminder that Kozzie was drafted at pick 12 standing 171cm. Nick's had a far superior 2 years at junior level. If you want a mid, agreed he's probably not your guy. Outside of Reid though I'm not convinced we will find the star mid that you're after. McKercher and Sanders probably the best mids to follow, but hard to get a good gauge when they played against such weak state teams that primarily filled their midfield with bottom agers. My view is that players like Watson are infinitely harder to find.
  7. Random Task replied to Random Task's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    I get it, but still think he needs to be in the conversation. If we end up with GCs pick a Watson, Duursma combo could be on the cards.
  8. Random Task replied to Random Task's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    Pickett and Watson starting small forwards. If one or some of Chandler, Spargo or ANB miss out so be it.
  9. Random Task posted a post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    This kid deserves his own thread now that the championship is done and we look to have a top 5-6 pick. 170cm small forward for Eastern Rangers, he kicked the most goals of the championships with 14 in 4 games. He is explosive, dual sided with excellent skills and has a good aerial presence as well. Jason Taylor said when drafting Kozzie that its hard to find genuine small forwards. This could be a golden opportunity to give us the most exciting and dangerous forward line in the league. Wouldn't surprise to see him a Roo after Reid and Walter have their names called out however.
  10. Random Task replied to Demonland's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    Even better
  11. Random Task replied to Demonland's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    I agree. We also beat them and the best team in the comp. Geelong think they're the danger... No. *Can someone please photoshop a mfc jumper on Walter white.
  12. Where can you view the full list?
  13. Random Task replied to dazzledavey36's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    Roos are a real wildcard here. They could get draft assistance either through the pre-listing of Sanders and the massaging of McKays FA compensation if he leaves. McKay leaving could leave them with either picks 2 and 3, 2 and 11, or 2 and 19. (Compensation being immediately after first pick, mid-first round, end of 1st round) If they can pre-list Sanders and Callinan through draft assistance I can't see the AFL massaging any FA compo and will most likely net them an end of First round or 2nd round compensation pick. So pick 19 or pick 21. They have a lot of capital to play with here including a valuable future 1st which will appeal.
  14. Random Task replied to Demonland's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    Whatever the case is, we have to get it perfectly right as there's not much wiggle room left before finals. A re-injury now would be catastrophic.
  15. Random Task replied to dazzledavey36's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    Agree with some concerns around Duursma, hoping for a strong end to the season because the talent is there but consistency is lacking. I think we shouldn't sleep on Watson. I'd have him in a heart beat and would make our forward half so much more dynamic.
  16. Random Task replied to dazzledavey36's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    Reid Watson Mckercher Curtain Duursma Sanders Caddy My preference is for Reid. But if we can somehow land 2 of the players underneath him then we are also laughing. Depending on how we view the development of Adams and D Turner, I could see O'Sullivan being on the hitlist as well. No doubt a bolter will come into first round calculations at some point. Looking at later picks. Archer Reid is a watch for me. 203cm forward that could compliment our list well. Would need to see some consistent performances in the back end of the u18 year with gippy but finished the championships ok for VC. If we want some more run out of the back half then Luamon Lual could be a good 2nd round option as well as Harry De Mattia. Midfield depth could have George Stevens as an option. Big bodied mid, not overly quick sure, but is probably one of the best kicks in the draft which would be a nice point of difference for us in the middle.
  17. If you listen to the AAA video Barrett even says that crows should be in the finals and sitting 5th or even 4th. I'm convinced he lurks on here and enjoys trolling us.
  18. Might be a trick of the camera but Jefferson looks like he's put a bit of weight on in his upper body in particular.
  19. Random Task replied to Demonland's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    108 point win over them in round 7. Charlie kicked 9 that day and already has 6 half way through the second quarter. Compromises the Coleman a bit. Percentage not much of a concern for us considering there draw earlier but chance to pass the cats.
  20. Random Task replied to Demonland's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    Carlton up 52 to 1 with 5 minutes to play in the first.
  21. Random Task replied to Demonland's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    Carlton v West Coast Five and a half minutes in and Carlton are 26 points to 0 and have had 43 possessions to 8. 186 challenger on the cards?
  22. Good chance to watch potential recruit Zane Duursma in action again for Casey.
  23. Allies dominate U18 All-Australian team after unbeaten carnival - Kynan Brown not named.
  24. It's spelt KFC.