Undeeterred

Mate you need to get a life. Get some perspective.

Of course you’re allowed your perspective. I just think it’s wildly wrong. Frost is, was and will be a dreadful footballer.

What nonsense. Frost was always limited, and we could hardly ship him fast enough when the offer for him came. And he was injured for a good portion of the couple of years that OMac played most of his games so it's just not valid to say Oscar was getting games ahead of him. And even if he was, it was because he's a better player than Frost. He probably did what he was told, for a start. But to suggest we should have put more games into him rather than Oscar is ridiculous.

You've obviously not improved from your prior incarnations, and I'm not going to debate with you further. I've established in fifteen seconds that you're talking utter [censored], and am not going to bother to be drawn further.

At risk of invoking with the old adage about arguing with fools, who exactly would you have played instead of Oscar in all these games he was ‘gifted’? Name names he should have been behind, but played in front of.

Sorry, but if you're saying that it's 'near unprecedented' for players to be delisted under 25 years, you have absolutely zero credibility. I'll give you a crack at clarifying, because that's surely not what you actually meant. And if you did, between the rest of us I think we could probably come up with 20 names just from our own club this has happened to. Corey Wagner, this year, for a start.

Well that’s a pretty dumb statement, given we got a trade for Watts.

Nobody questions winning the Hogan trade, it’s giving up a Max King type for May that got people fired up

Saw Tom in my local cafe today - whatever is happening, he's looking very happy and relaxed. Hope that's a good thing

That's probably fair enough. I don't think I intended to display a 'just get over it' attitude, but you're probably right. I just don't think that was what caused him to blow up his talent, and Melbourne supporters in particular give him an easy out for it. I could easily be wrong.

Some of this applies to me, and some obviously doesn't. None of it is that relevant to the point I made though. For what it's worth, I agree with you - it's incredibly sad to see where Jesse has ended up. I was beyond excited when he arrived and thought we had landed the next Wayne Carey I suspect Jesse was heading down the wrong path before all this stuff happened. And his own illness obviously affected his mindset, you're absolutely right. I could be wrong, but my gut reaction has always been that it's naive to assume that what happened to Jesse's father destroyed his football career. Who knows I guess.

Most people lose their father at some point. I lost mine in my mid-20s and my career is going along great guns. I wish we'd all stop making this excuse for him.

Going out for a pizza will be nice.

This is the key. With the system set up so that only a relatively small number of players make free agency at a time, there's no big batch of players that pop out the back end. In Geelong's case, for example, someone like Esava might take this opportunity to bail but he can't, and other teams can't get him without giving up valuable picks. So he's stuck now behind Hawkins and Cameron, but can't do anything about it for like 4 years

?

Aren't you the one who says about Ben Brown that when great players land on us we don't complain? I'd much rather Mihocek than Brown...

Utter nonsense. He's tough as. I'd love him to be squeezed out and I'd have him in a second

He'd struggle to get within a bull's roar of 60 trying to pick up half volleys off the deck on the lead all season, which is what he'll get if he comes to us.

God, why??? Let it go man.

It's not just social media. Demonland is as bad.

And Jack Grimes, although that was navicular as well

How on earth did it come to this??

Ah, I see. What an [censored] that man is.

Why would he? He's having a ball in the media, probably earning a fortune. He's probably happy he's left this basket case of a club.

Completely agree. My comment was about Salem.