Melb-A-Toast

I've noticed that Salem does not have the extra space and time that he was allowed in previous years. Opposition coaches are making an impact.

When was the last time a McDonald wasn't in the side? Could it be over a decade?

Great analysis. It is a change that could be interpreted in the same manner as they do after an awarded mark. Giving the power to the "first to the ball" maybe even interpret as a tackle cannot be made until it is clearly in the possession of opposing player, rather than when a player is still attempting to gain control. I remember great exponents of getting rewarded by not taking possesion like Keith Greig, Kevin Bartlett, Schimmelbusch and Robert Flower. This would also most likely speed up the movement of the ball.

I'm pretty certain this is game day room, but happy to accept constructive criticism. ?

Good thing Razor Ray was selected for the Eagles

He was magnanimous to Melbourne last weekend

That leaves me a bit frosty this morning...?

Nice. Though I was hoping that it could be additional revenue for MFC. Are these under licence from MFC?

Just sent an email to the demon shop. Got a reply that they have no plans...

I don't know if this has been raised before. There is likely to be a need to wear masks for longer time beyond lockdown. Does MFC have branded masks available? It could be a good way to promote our brand and support.

Unfortunately, he only gets under the radar from pundits and other team supporters. The opposition coaches are well aware of his influence. But as he is so good, most of their tactics are not effective - long may that continue.

If he has another kid, then the name could be Mel Bennel - pronunced Melbourne 'ell!

I will not attend a match until Melbourne win. ?

I hope you are right

Nice. Breville better with Neville Jetta

That was from sen stats in 2019. https://www.sen.com.au/news/2019/07/10/who-are-the-most-accurate-and-inaccurate-players-in-the-afl/

Melbourne Goals Behinds Other Total shots Accuracy % Jayden Hunt 18 10 4 32 56.3 Christian Petracca 17 10 7 34 50 Sam Weideman 11 8 4 23 47.8 Tom McDonald 18 15 6 39 46.2 Jake Melksham 10 5 7 22 45.5 Jeff Garlett 9 9 3 21 42.9 James Harmes 10 15 4 29 34.5

Melksham is elite. Left and right

Has Simon Goodwin failed as a coach? He introduced the gameplan whilst under Paul Roos that provided the drastically improved scoring in Roos's 3rd year. He led the team to missing finals by percentage in 2017 and then continued growth in 2018. 2019 was disappointing. 2020, 1 game has been played. Bad game. The coaching team will address the shortcomings, or if not, then you may have some good points about his lack of prowess in coaching. To me, the game plan is sound, execution at critical moments has been oscillating. Goodwin brings good people management, we have good player development and he has sound tactical knowledge of football. These are critical in an elite football club. There is a strong case for staying the course.

He'd be a nice addition around high half forward too. With his and Melksham's elite kicking, the inside 50 conversion should drastically improve.

Garry was more influential in his games. He had a bigger impact in games earlier in his career. Neitz was no slouch but he really started to be more impactful from 96. Garry was moved on the ball when the game was in the balance, and he was very effective as a pinch hitter. David was moved to the backline when we needed to stem the flow, but he was most valuable as a forward target - decoy or prime. Garry's back ruined his last years and David was only majorly impacted in his last year.

Isn't the new Perth stadium the same dimensions as MCG?

I didn't know that crossword scratchies were a thing.. A lifelong learner I am ?

I wonder whether how that could be played. I am pondering the many times that a ball is neutral and two or more opponents go for the ball. The second player may have a near impossible task to stop/slow their attack on the ball

My vocabulary is limited. But I noticed that you attacked me without actually responding to the topic.