Pennant St Dee

Don Pyke.

Pert and Roffey gone it is what it is allow the media to speculate and devour the carcass of what is currently an easy kill. They called for change at the MFC with the off field matters (well published) this year and last, yet when change occurs their manta and position is toward continued turmoil not change to move forward. It’s time for the playing group and football department to knuckle down, less media and less incidents to draw further attention. just focus on the infield side of things next season and let that do the talking. And Chris from Camberwell if you’re on here for god sake stop getting on radio claiming to speak for the majority of Melbourne supporters, you certainly don’t speak for me and quite frankly are embarrassing most times you go to air on Dwayne Russell’s show.

Absolutely horrific and a parents nightmare. If the family are supportive of it, I think it would be a wonderful tribute to do something for the memory of a young Dee’s fan in Rd1

I could see a world where we bounce back just with good pre seasons and a clear run at it for Oliver and Trac plus natural progression for Windsor. I don’t expect us to win the flag next year even with the above occurring. Our next serious tilt will come from Rivers, Mcvee, Windsor and JVR taking the next step along with Petty getting a good run with injuries and holding down at key role (preferred down back but possibly swinging forward). I still consider the coaching staff having the tough love conversation with Kossie regarding his brain fades needs to be had If they do that and it doesn’t all fall to Max, Trac, Oliver, May and Kossie having to carry all our hopes, we will fine and contending

Why bother your dealing with someone unreasonable who talks of the last 3 years being a total failure because we didn’t win a flag or final- forget the fact there were certain circumstances and we put ourselves in the top 4 after home and away season Wanting Goody to debut Jefferson, even though he’s not ready Spargo being no good because he’s small- forget the fact he’s our best link player in transition and probably the best decision maker with ball in hand Doesn’t understand despite being underdone, when he plays Petty takes one of if not the best opposition defender away from a younger forward And time is quickly running out FFS, another who is incapable of seeing the change in the group happening before his eyes

He’ll also be starting to talk to clubs and managers now, figuring out which clubs have shown interest in players whose interviewed who and then do the comparisons with the draft order

@spirit of norm smith @Adam The God @dazzledavey36 Wouldnt think Boxshall will be there at pick 83 in the draft

I’m not sure whether he goes main draft or rookie, there are big questions on his kicking

He has huge upside, very good inside mid and elite endurance. Courage can not be questioned and played key position for most of his junior career at community and PSA level. Kicking is his weakness but certainly worth a look for any club with a late pick in the ND or even as a rookie. He’s an absolute beast was BOG in the WAFL colts GF right up until the last 15 minutes.

It’s not just MFCSS, it’s a real possibility. However if the club believes he’s the one at that pick then they back themselves to create the environment and put things in place where he wants to stay. He played as an underager in 23 so has that connection with Kolt and Kentfield from state squad

And 2006 born, only just very late in December

Yep Clang looks older than he is. Absolute ripper who likes to run hard from defence to create options.

Yes they are reliable traits to look for, a lot of clubs overlooked Simon Black because he lacked pace, but what they didn’t take into account was he was a very good 400m runner with great endurance and by all accounts a very good character.

As Paul Connors said Melbourne were never giving up a top 5 pick.

Within reason in regard to Roos comments, 2km time and character are great but you still need some physical traits and footy ability. There’s plenty of players who are of fine character and run elite times but just undersized and that’s a big reason they remain at state league, country footy level. Hamish Davis is of excellent character and ran top 5 in the 2km, but he isn’t a top 10 pick

It’s nothing to do with the AFL, in competition test is a WADA matter

Yes we seem to be a club who backs ourselves. Things can always change once you get settled into an environment and the day to day training and with a new group. Just passing on what I have heard

Fairly big risk, which I have heard from a few

+1

I’m not upset at taking Langford

I’d probably take Langford, but it’s marginal. And I also like Draper

In that scenario I’d take Draper at 5

Yes I think we will if either of Lalor or Langford are there. Don’t get me wrong I do rate Smith, I just have the other 2 ahead

I expect us to have the choice between Lalor and Langford who I have ahead of Smith. Richmond will IMO take one of those 2 at 1 and I expect it to be Lalor. They get the big bodied mid and IMO will take Smith at 6 who compliments the big body. They may take him at 1 if they really want Smith, but I think they take Lalor

Taking into account Langfords ability to play forward,whilst they are both big mid types I wouldn’t say no to both. Windsor potentially spending more time through the middle gives us some leg speed through there with Sharp and Langdon providing repeat endurance run. Kossie, Trac rotating through with Oliver (hopefully fitter and focused), Viney and Rivers it should give us greater depth through the middle which is much needed. Having said that if North go tall I can’t see Draper getting past the Crows and don’t see Carlton not taking O’Sullivan if he’s there. 1. Lalor/Langford 2. Tauru??? 3. O’Sullivan 4.Draper 5. Langford/Lalor At this point I would expect Richmond to take Smith, leaving Smilie and Reid for the Saints. They need midfield depth and I see them taking Smilie Either way we get a really good midfielder IMO with 5 and expect it will be one of Lalor, Langford or Smilie