sydneydee

Had a Melbourne membership call last year offering a special deal. I told her that everyone in my immediate family would buy a full membership as soon as Goody is gone. To her credit she wrote down my pledge and said she would pass it on. I asked her if others have said similar and she said a lot of people she is calling are disillusioned with where the club is. His legacy is already tainted as he is putting his own interest above the needs of the club. He needs to go before everyone loses hope.

If we fix this, we fix our team

Regardless of the two wins, he needs to go. The club expected a high finals finish to the home and away season. As soon as finals are not mathematically possible he should be removed for a fresh coach for the pre season.

It’s depressing that it has come to this. How can we be so consistent at being a rabble of a club.

Another Goodwin masterclass. no clues

For the sake of the future of the club, he must go now. I will remember the highs of 21, but his legacy will be decimating a top quality list. The members have spoken with a 15% drop off. People just don’t want to watch his trash gameplan

Plenty will sign up once Goody and his boring game plan have left the building.

Give it a rest, Goody is on record saying our preferred entry is a forward pocket stoppage. They are coached to play this way. That is the problem when you turn elite talents into robots. They lose enjoyment and look to move into other systems that are not defence first.

Finals will not be a chance as we lose our best players for little return in this years trade period. MFC can’t afford to be a basket case again. We are down 10k members already due to a game experience that is not worth watching. Change now, is the best way to give hope to the fans and let our stars be allowed to play their natural style.

Isn’t it unusual for a nominee in a team that lost? Congrats to the young man.

Just watched the presser and he actually said that the forward half is not the problem. Say what? He was happy with 26 scores from 40 entries! Does he not realise that 18 of those scores were behinds? Does he know that there was no system? Better system would result in more entries. Practicing goal kicking would result in better conversions. He talks about us being out of form, well perhaps only play 100% fit players and play players in their best positions. With a reported strong off season there is no reason why our players struggle to run out quarters.

Laughable, he clearly has lost the group. No idea on a modern day game plan and is too arrogant to listen to others. For the sake of any chance of future membership he must be removed immediately.

This thread isn’t about a wasted dynasty, it’s about a coach who inherited an amazing list and amazing system who systemically destroyed the list over the last few years. He achieved this through poor team selection, lack of ability to make game day tactical moves, a very poor outdated game plan with a stubbornness to change. my belief is that we would have won more finals with a more nimble, tactical robust coach who doesn’t play favorites. Look at poor Spargo, twice he has come back early from LTI and twice got injured (different injuries) on 1st game back. This is on the entire coaching team and the head coach is ultimately accountable for performance and on this metric he has failed. the time to go has already past.

When on song he is a delight to watch. He appears to be struggling with his new role and we don’t play to his strengths. i can understand why he would want to move if the media can be believed.

Of course Goodwin is the problem and to salvage the season he should be removed ASAP. Everything he has tried to do/ said he will do has failed or not eventuated. He is stuck in his ways. It only took to round 2 to coach form the boundary ffs. Spargo on his day is a gun but it is not fair to play him when he is not 100% against north we were too slow, too small, unskilled, unstructured and couldn’t land a tackle. Our positional moves both assistant coaches and players have not worked, with a number of players regressing in last years output. That is 100% on the coach. The only positives I saw from the game was Chandler and Lindsay’s performance and we 1 game closer to sacking Goodwin who has destroyed the premiership list he inherited. Please ghostwriter, do not respond to this post as I am allowed to have a different view to yourself.