Canplay

I think Paul is proving to be great communicator and can’t knock any of then reset strategy - the mistakes made were all on Perts watch. I’ve much more confidence in this administration than the incompetent management of Rofey and Pert

Once again, I'm sure in Freo's press release, Tim Lamb will be praised as being great to deal with.... In a universally agreed weak and compromised draft - why wouldn't you posture and hold for their pick 19.... instead of sealing this on day 2 of the trade period - even if you have to concede and take 23 later in the period - at least have a crack Tim!!

Lever the perfect one to move on - he was already slow and now his ankle is cooked and he's a defensive liability - Turner the intercept defender we need....

Green continues to be a cheerleader - the captain of morale but seems incapable of critical thinking - when what we need is a ruthless strategic thinker - not a waterboy

Dee’s by 35…. The TMac factor!

Lever

Lever a defensive liability again - opponents work off him into space so easily

May is a great player but a culture cancer - such an ordinary bloke

Lever cannot defend one on one and the whole competition knows you can’t let him sag off - keep him accountable for a man - then work through him - can’t defend - gives soft frees in contest because he can’t compete - if the ball hits the ground he’s awful and looks to have lost all pace. I’d seriously drop to Casey to work on defensive craft as the comp won’t let him be a loose interception defender - and bring back TMac who can win a contest.

Out : Lever, Laurie, AJ (susp) In : TMac, Viney, JVR but really - just as long as Lever has spell at Casey

How did Jake Lever come straight back into the side last week? was ordinary against swans and deplorable against saints… Can’t defend one on one and far too lose. Bring back TMac and drop Lever - Tom is better in air, judgement and can actually defend!! Lever back to Casey!

Love to know what top AFL attributes Jason Taylor saw in Kolt that made him a first round selection

Why do now stop the game for a rolled ankle??

I would be rapt with Bevo - a creative culture builder - he’s done a great job at bulldogs but now just in danger of staying too long. Bevo still has good mates at club - Neita, Hopgood and co - so sure they would be in his ear….

Fritch had to be dropped after last week. Giving nothing offensively or defensively- just a soft liability.

In - Turner, Kozzy, Lever Out - Fritch, Howes, Lindsay Sub - Viney

4 years to go and he’s a liability in the centre bounces and no other positional options. Tim Lamb list management 101….

We’ve got huge problems, viney’s reaction time has slowed and he can’t win a clearance - and he can’t be trusted to kick it into Fwd 50 - don’t know what role he can play for the last 4 years of contract! Fritch - going through motions - dialling in a performance and should be dropped after some soft efforts May - lost a step of pace and won’t be the wall he once was but there’s no heir apparent. Rivers - has a crack but just turns the ball over by hand and foot far too often. But I still think he needs to replace Viney in centre. Melksham - getting his super topped up over past two years but we should have moved on this year and fought for Membrey or Stringer. Van Rooyen going backwards - confidence shot and needs coaching to be more active (on the move) in fwd line. Goodwin - his game style over past 5 years has worn out players and he can’t pivot. No longer inspiring a performance and can’t solve forward line inefficiency issues - time to go.

Jack Viney cannot be the one with the final fwd 50 kick

He’s changed nothing - same gameplan, same predictability and same fwd line inefficiency. I’d like to see Hird have a crack with this group.

Paul Hopgood should get Dee’s gig

Tim Lamb shooting the lights out again. I’m sure he’ll offer a second rounder and GWS will praise him as being good to deal with….

Not sure he stacks up against the Hawks new breed of fast, all day running bulls…. But not many do

Time to go Kate

Paul Hopgood a great call - company CEO - great people skills - unified the past players association