Moonshadow

Getting a bit loose on detail in your haste to outrage, or what? Of course, none of us really know, but most reports say Frost wants $650k while Tomlinson deal is for $500k. And Tomlinson is a free agent, whilst Frost could generate a draft pick. Not that they would play in the same position anyway. And "another indictment on Goodwin and co at the hands of Brisbane"??? That made me lol! We're you shaking a fist in the air as you wrote that?

There's your first mistake Binny.

Please do.

Hyperbole bs

Yes. He gave Richmond very good service and was a worthwhile contributor to 2 flags. That should just about be enough.

I would've thought even pick 5 on its own to be a bit rich for a guy who has chronic injury issues over many years. 2 picks inside the top 10. Madness if true.

Pick 39 actually. And Richmond wanted to keep him, but as a free agent they couldn't afford his asking price and years.

Good for him, wise move. Handy player.

Born in Vic, but he was in Queensland until a teenager. Also spent time in WA. Edot. Apologies, didn't see that it had been covered

Explains you've eaten too many biscuits in your time.

There's one to bookmark Uncle @Bitter but optimistic

Improve the list, get fit, better draw, win games and the crowds will come. In 2018 our avg home attendances was only 10,000 less than Collingwood's: 50k vs 40k. And we played less home games at the G than the Pies.

Where's/who's Prodee?

Even then, did Frosty come out and request a trade to Hawks?

Did he? I can't find anything from him, his manager or Hawks

Bull [censored]. Scully's best was for GWS. He's a plodder at Hawthorn

What's he like as a footballer, as opposed to off field? Think I'd rather Harley Bennell.

Brown kicked 2 goals 3 behinds from 17 disp as a key forward. Inaccurate, yes. But hardly "shut down". In a 5 point margin game, I'd say 2g 3b proved to be very handy Just my view.

Sure, but that's not what a key position player is. No biggie. C ya

Says you, so it must be. You're happy for Salem to play on Rievoldt or Lynch then. Good for you. Lol!

Tayla Harris?

Would he improve our list? Does he meet a need? Is there anyone better available? Would he cost much?

He also needed a slap across the face on numerous occasions. Remember when he was one of the instigators of telling Bailey that the players weren't going to do the 3 km time trial (or it might've been the Tan??)