Moonshadow

Yes, I see your point. However, I hardly think GWS or GC will take what CS has to say seriously. They know what they have to do to make us take him, and so far they have both indicated that they will do just that. I was making the point (separate from yours) that it annoys me to hear CS talk about the list and up coming draft as if it is his place to manage that. It was one of the main criticisms of him last year, that he tends to get involved unduly in matters of the FD.

I did like the tread title on Demonology that said something like: "Jamar admits: I only like the tapping part!"

God no please!

Honestly, get over it. And if a young 'gun' wanted to come to us in similar circumstances...? I think we'd be rubbing our hands together with delight. This Scully sooking is getting very boring.

Is this CS picking the list again? What MFC team did he write on a napkin this time? Keep your hands out of the football dept, Cam. Not impressed, if true.

Honestly, we are hardly top 4 material so let's stop puffing our chest out to denigrate a young man who will, in all likelyhood, prove to be a very good player, whatever he is paid. Sure, he's not staring ATM, but there's a reason he was pick 1 and is on good coin. FFS, we are 1 game + % off last place! I find it interesting to read threads about who'd we like (or not) to get with FA and RFA coming in at the end of the year. We won't hear any players saying before the season is finished that they'll be leaving for greener pastures. Yet many of us hope like hell that one or two come across to us, and you can be sure that MFC will currently be in the ear of managers for Cloke, Chapman, Sewel, et al. They'd be stupid not to be. Is that why we are so p!ssed with Scully, that he wasn't honest with us? Or is it that he's left to earn more $ than we could pay him, money that will set him and his family up for life? It is not that I particularly like the guy or follow his career, it's just that I can't see the point in wasting time and energy carrying on like a child about it. It makes us look like a bunch of sooks. Surely we have greater issues to discuss, considering where WE are at now.

Unduly rough contact? Intentional? Contact severe? Just shoot the dog.

Oh, well its sorted then. Thanks for letting us know. We were all concerned.

Yeah, I think you are right on that one. Martin seems to really enjoy having the first ruck roll to himself. He seems to need consistency and continuity in one position. Looks more settled covering the ground as a whole and not being kept solely up forward, in the back line or on the pine.

I reckon it won't be long before Judd starts squirrelling or doing a Hopoate. Great player, champion, but what a weasel act to do to a defencless player on the ground. If I was a Norf supporter, I would be very proud of my players reaction to Judd's arm twist. Putting him straight on his arse.

Every game is winnable. I thought we'd have 3-4 games won in the first half of the season. I honestly don't think that we can win more than 2 for the rest of the season. Who else are we likely to beat? GWS and GC? After GCs performance today, that's not a lock in. I think we'll finish 16th on % only from GWS and GC.

Great comeback match from McDonald. For a young guy to have a punctured lung (or what ever was wrong with his lung) and play so well on his return match was a highlight for me. Showed considerable poise and maturity for a teenager. Thank god we re-signed him!

Has anyone considered that we are only one game (and %) away from last?

Would he prefer to stay at Geelong and end his days as a one club player? Leaving as a FA would perhaps dilute his legacy down in Sleepy Hollow. Some players are not concerned with this. To others this is important, especially if they have played during a great flag era. If he was available to us, I guess we'd have to weigh up what he would provide (and cost) in only one or two years, as opposed to a 25/26/27 year old high level player who might be with us for 4-5 yrs, into a so-called premiership window. These sorts of issues are going to be more and more important in the next few years as FAs and RFAs come into the picture. What do other think about FAs vs RFAs?

Didn't know I was your 'son', old man. It's pretty hard to reason with someone who uses the justification above to prove their case. If you argue with fools, you end up looking like one. Over and out on this thread.

He won't go. As pathetic an argument as it is, he will claim he was tackling the opposition player. Did anyone notice how Adams used his leg to try and kick Judd away while he was on the ground. Clearly he was in pain.

What is there to say. You've done a lot of work there, Captain Obvious.

] Just a midfielder??? Do you know anything about footy? It's commonly accepted that the midfield is where matches are won. All the names you mentioned, except for Jones, are only battlers based upon this year's effort. Sad but true. And you could add a number of others to that list, such as Trengove, Davey, Bail, Green and Petterd. Based upon this year, that is. Moloney is struggling for form, but let's not throw the baby out with the bath water.

Won't be cited. Protected species. No chance. "insufficient force"

Oh, we'll, it's decided then. No more to say. Thanks for letting us know.

No. Your username says it all.

Yeah, I think you might be right. But I wouldn't be surprised if Martin is offered around for a trade at years end, as i believe he is worth more game time than we are giving him, and ruckmen with a few years under their belt are worth a bit.

If we picked him up, we would probably look to have some/all of Gawn, Martin and Spencer move on

This is getting ridiculous. So the reining B&F winner, experienced, big bodied, good leader, still relatively young, should be let go of because he has been badly out of form this year? And us anonymous hacks somehow know better than the FD! And I thought only Tigers supporters ate their own!

I gave up tuning in to his crap. No point trying to counter his views as he simply doesn't care to listen to what others say. And will never apologise or acknowledge when he has been proven wrong. You know the saying... If you argue with fools for too long, you begin to look like one.