Moonshadow

So you're saying there's still a chance? ?

Would be interesting to see what might happen if another club invited him to train over summer. Work his legs hard, see if he can stand up to it.... literally.

I agree...if that's permitted by @Demon3

Sounds like Weid 2.0!

As expected.

If Hawthorn offered him 2 years, or even 2 years with games played incentive for 3, would you match it? I don't think a 1 year deal would get him to us. With 3 knee recos, only the Hawks doc can fix him

I see it how it actually was. You see it as it might have been but wasn't. Which one is lazy?

3 x knee recos. Pass.

Pick 10 (O'Brien)and following year what ended up being pick 19 (Stocker) for Lever will be a steal for us in the years to come.

I'd say strength through the midriff, hips and legs would be a greater priority. This will help stop him getting pushed off the contest, which happens regularly

No thanks. No DHs beyond this point.

Eddie will be 33 at the start of next year and have at least 312 games under his belt. Great player, great career, but time's up.

Agree on this part.

I guess you missed the italic part in my post which said "at the moment". Gus would not get us a 1st rounder now. He's has had one good year. I do not rate the Brownlow count as a true reflection of a player's value. He was not 3rd best in the league last year. Langdon has shown consistent good form last year and this year. They play different roles, neither is a particulary good kick. Not saying I want Gus traded by any means, but i do know we need outside run more than an inside mid at the moment. There's that phrase again! Cerra and Langdon for Gus is an LSD induced dream. Where do we sign? Not going to happen.

What about: OUT: MFC 2019 R1 and R2 picks (3+23, assuming GCS get 1+2PP) IN: B Hill + Langdon+ Freo 2019 R1 (about 9) No doubt Freo would think that unders and try and work Gus into the equation

Wrong thread

I read it that he thinks MFC should make a play for Hill. His opinion, rather than that we will

I would think Brayshaw for Langdon would be a fairer trade to an objective observer. Both about high 2nd rounder in value at the moment

You left out the bit where we wouldn't go for another untried coach and would need to pay $1.5mill + to get a worthwhile, experienced coach to replace Goody.

I'd rather give up more for Hill and/or Langdon. Or is Smith a FA? Still, at 31 we should not top up his super for 1 year + maybe a 2nd year at Casey. At least Lewis gave us about 2.5 years, albeit of arguable quality

Who'd have thunk Caro to be the voice of reason, hey? ?

Fake news. Roos has acknowledged he is a Melbourne fan now who watches us closely, I saw him at the G wearing a MFC scarf last year. I also see PJ at the footy regularly with his missus both decked out in MFC merch and closely following the game. He was there vs Carlton a few weeks ago. I'll agree they needed at least 2 more years (probably 4) to really set us up. They left us in a good position, but a half baked position with a dodgey oven.

Who will be 31years old at the start of the year. Pass.

Mate, you've said nothing factual to back up your hate for May, only ranting, sweeping statements and opinions. It's clear you dislike him, we get it, you don't need to continue on and on and on. The gif I posted sums up your position perfectly. C ya.

Blah, blah, blah, blah....... Just saying it more times doesn't convince anyone