Slartibartfast

The thing that frustrates me with you Picket is I’m never quite sure where you stand!😀

Because it could be better. On your theory Viney doesn't come in?

Not so Bin, I’m on the Picket train and would replace AJ with JvR. In four games AJ has had 23 disposals, two marks, 2 goals and 18 hit outs. I said it about Fullarton and I think the same with AJ; people are looking for positives but the reality is he’s not AFL standard yet, he drops marks he should take, he isn’t clean below his knees, his disposal is poor and when teams play two rucks against us because of Max he isn’t competitive. He was quite poor against Callum Brown as well. Like everyone I love his attack on the ball, but you need more. IMO JvR is a better player all round and if you compared the two players JvR is clearly better. What people are doing is saying that JvR is well below his best so shouldn’t be in the team. Even well below his best JvR offers more. To those that say AJ has played in winning teams and JvR hasn’t I say it is correlation not causation. Our results would have been the same with either. It probably comes down to JvR’s mindset. If he believes he needs another game at Casey then fine but if he’s got his confidence back it’s a no brained for me.

If that’s what you took out of my post then I’m either not expressing myself clearly or you comprehension is very poor.

Oh yes I would Dazzle. The system is broken. Every time a FS or Academy is taken ahead of you your pick is now one lower. We would have had Mills and we bid on Ashcroft. We probably win a flag in 2023 if the Pies don’t have two Daicos boys. Win or lose, at least you’d know the system isn’t rigged. Who knows if Viney was the reason we won in 2021, we might have been much better off or we might have missed the 8 in a fair draft system. I believe the system is unfair and want it changed and whilst FS are romantic I think it’s a small price to pay for a better system.

So many GF have been won because of FS. Collingwood with two Daicos boys, Geelong with Albert’s, Hawkins and Scarlett. Brisbane get two Ashcroft boys while contending and winning flags with Will winning the NS. Added to that the Academies gift players to club. Add Coleman to Brisbane, Heeney, Mills and Guldon to Swans. The Suns will be very powerful for years with 2 or three more first pick academy kids to join them at the end of this year. It corrupts the competition. How do you think NM fans feel as all those players are taken from the draft as they struggle? FS romantic? Go and watch Days of Our Lives if you want romantic, I want a fairer competition where more teams have a chance. I’m with RJay but we ain’t going to get it. Perhaps teams should be limited to one top 10 pick every 3 years or some such rule and no more trading your top pick down for a points bonanza, that’s just a Rory.

You'll be pleased to hear they couldn't do it.

AMW and McAdam also miss. I miss them and held high hopes for both this year.

Good to hear all AFL players in attendance. How did AMW and McAdam go, light training presumably? Thanks as always for your input.

I think too much is being made of the soccer game. These sessions are for recovery, get the bruises out, get the legs moving. Further because the main weekly training session is at Casey we’ve no idea what they are doing there. We don’t know what they are doing indoors. We’ve too little information to judge. Until you look at the whole training program I think many here are drawing too much from far too little information.

Where is Stevethemanjordan when you want him. It’s very simple. No Oscar, no Freo.

Along with Max, Barry Prendergast’s best picks. 😂

😎😎 Where is Steve? Bin, redemption.

He’s played two and won two. Not all toys are shiny. He’s the future, the alternatives to him are probably not. Invest in him and it will reap dividends. One thing you know about Kolt, he brings energy and maximum effort and that is infectious in team sport.

Someone suggested this and got shouted down. Rarely have I seen such an ordinary game talked up last week and a similar game tonight talked down. Reality is there wasn’t much difference other than he got a longer go at it so people noticed.

It was a good win but don't get too carried away, Richmond were worse than terrible. A good game to get out of form players into some form. Difficult for Jeffo, he didn't do anything wrong but AJ and JvR just go everything.

It will be interesting to see Fullarton again. He didn't get in the way in the forward line last week because he was rarely there. He only played 60% game time with much of that in the ruck. His rucking was against Oscar Mac so that really wasn't a serious test. I'm struggling to see so many positives in a six possession six hit out game and I worry about Max having to do so much rucking. But he was part of the winning team so deserves his second go. Really the choice between Tom and Tom isn't going to define the game.

Is it possible to have an opinion that isn't "personal"? Anyway I agree with you re Campbell. If Nank gets Gawny, which he always tries to do, we have Fullarton as back up. With Campbell we have a real ruck, Campbell is a much more "belts and braces" approach. My reading if Fritta comes back that was the plan from day one. Why would you only play him for a half at Casey when he's out of form? This, coupled with Goody's comments in yesterday's presser suggest he's a good chance of coming back. If he does come back it suggests his demotion last week was a penalty rather than form.

Sadly, no Lever. TC in rehab.

Perhaps we should all put in to help. A Go Fund Me page? I'm in.

If he wasn’t fit enough surely you’d play him at Casey to get a full game. The most sensible thing is to start him and sub him off if he runs out of gas. But really, they wouldn’t pick him if he couldn’t play 4 quarters.

I didn't want to start a new thread but do Casey have a practice match this weekend and if so, where and when? Thanks for any help.

I don’t think 12 disposals and two goals against Howes is killing him, Green is a fantastic player and Howes is still learning. IMO he’s becoming the new whipping boy much as AJ is becoming a fan favourite. It will be interesting to see how the FD react. Only forced changes this week I’d suggest unless someone really played well for Casey. May and Turner come in if fit.

I know this will be howled down but TMac is too good to not have in the 22. If May comes back I’d be moving Petty forward. AJ was poor in the ruck against Brown and JvR is much better. Jeffo has no intensity and I’d prefer Turner and Petty to AJ and Jeffo. If Spargs is ready he’s a class above Hendo. Wont happen, but that’s my take.

Good luck Andy and Nasher. See you on the other side!