old dee

I truely don’t understand the Lever in Tmac out selection. If it goes poorly we could cough up a loss here when we should win. Kolt’s form yesterday at Preston suggests that his demotion was necessary, I will put that down as a positive. Dees by 8 points.

DJ any game were you win by a large margin is a good time!

If you consider the quality of the oposition then it makes JVR's performance even worse. It's hard to believe after his first year results that he is this bad.

Yep he will a good KPF at Casey

Sorry DJ I should have said Preston no idea where Coburg came from. The joy of the ageing process well that is my excuse. And I know where both are.

If you are a good KPF and cannot dominate at Casey against Cobury you are in serious trouble.

If that is the worst thing that happens to me today I will be very happy.

I don't agree but like I said both are not senior level quality.

I did alter it deanox. Should have said rested. I think I was agreeing with you.

I know it is like comparing the worst from the second worst but Fullarton is a better player than Jefferson.

He has been our best tall defender all season. Hardly put a foot wrong. Saying omitted is an insult. If he is being tested say so.

It beggars belief.

It would have no doubt cost you way more than a free coffee to get there Bob.

Hay carefully!

You must be on the outer binman Every member I know got the invitation.

You have to wonder what the selection committee had for lunch today. The most bizarre change that I can remember for some time. We return a player who has been out for 2 months after Ankle surgery and played 2 20 minute quarters last week for a player who has been the rock of our defence for the whole year.

Hang on there is BT!!!!!

It would get in the road of ads and bloke [censored] by the presenters. Anyway who needs someone who knows what he is talking about!

You have my vote.

There are A very large number of commentators on AFL. All trying to justify their existance. Some make valid comments about us. We are after all 14th on the ladder, that means we have put in some very poor games. A lot of the critism is justified however the big mistake that loyal MFC fans make is reading/ listening to the many trying to justify their existsance. Don't listen to them watch the games, form your own opinion and forget the hundreds of scribes.

I am with you froggy. We have been massive under achievers since 21. However i think it is as much the loss of players as Goodwin's ability. Jackson replaced by JVR a big loss. Brown replaced by no one another big loss. Brawshaw loss replaced by a couple of kids who are showing promise. Clarry went missing for two seasons with mental problems. Smith gone forever with nose problems. The start of this year what was that? Players or coaching.

You have given me a smile jd10. That does not equate to a lot of pressure.

What is the reason he should be in other your desire to have him in? He played half a game after 2 months out injured which involved surgery. It is not a must final. I agree sharp isn't!

The original stated return was said to be 2 games at Casey. He played half a game last week. I expect he will be at Casey again this week. With an ankle injury he would have had little running over the last 2 months.

Correct I realised my error and corrected. When were these seasons? I suspect pre 2023. 2024 he only played part of 1 game and 2023 he spent most of the year as Casey. IMO it is a long time since he has been more than average.