DeeSpencer

Does he though? He’s born in January and has spent the entire year as a full time footballer. He’ll obviously get stronger but I doubt power will ever be a big part of his game, he’s got a wiry frame. Reid might have more of a bulky frame to add power once he gets in to a full time environment.

We were 3 goals up because we had the wind for 2 of the 3 quarters. Freo scored 1 goal in the first and third. We scored 1 goal in the second. The game was going to tighten up in the last and make scoring in to the wind incredibly hard. 1 goal 4 in the 3rd quarter was where we lost it.

The Hore holding the ball came about because she tried to do it all herself. Same as her shot at goal in the 3rd quarter with 2 spare alone in the square. Good player, but needs to work with her team mates to go up another level. That’s harder when half of them are unknowns.

Please. They lost 4 best 21 players in trade week. Have another 6 out injured. And lost 2 more in game. Freo were always going to charge late with the wind. Game was lost in the 3rd not converting chances but the forward line today had 2 players who’d get a game in full strength side and 4 who aren’t up to it.

Haha that’s not a tackle

Trademark horrendous weak Bannan contest as the ball went inside 50 there. She’s so bad

Mackin injured. Zanker possible acl? Just fold the comp

No idea why Hore wasn’t back the whole quarter and a bad effort from Colvin to concede 2 goals in quick succession. We need a miracle now

Wrong thread

And then we get one back. Schofield melt incoming

The girl who looks no older than 13 is hopeless

How about the shape he was in when he turned up for preseason and was right down the back in the running? Or how bad he was in his positioning even with basic around the ground work rate in the ruck? Or his initial form when sent back to Casey? He was never serious about fighting for his spot, the moment he lost it he was off elsewhere.

Hungry hungry Hore. Had 2 in the square loose

And not once have Melbourne bagged him. If he was to open his mouth they’d be plenty coming back the other way. He had 17 chances to impress the coaches and it never worked. Goody gave him a lot longer run than it deserved really.

I think he’s super difficult to rate, I’m not even sure where I’d have him. But you see the fast hands right? He has the ball and then it’s out right away and often straight to a player in space.

Reid’s a better goal kicker (does spend more time forward) but the biggest point of difference is his hands are on an entirely different level. Some of, if not the quickest and most creative hands you’ll ever see. There’s plenty of concerns - is he physical, is he athletic enough, can he add distance and flatten his kicking - although they are similar (if lesser) concerns for me with Jagga. But his hands might be the standout trait of any player in the draft. If you think there’s enough scope to develop the rest of his game you got to take him very early.

I agree with that. Except with his overhead marking and pace I’d start him half forward rather than wing. Kicking hasn’t looked right this year but there’s no doubt he can roost it. He reminds me of Rozee. He was the best player at under 16’s, the best last year and has just had a shocking year with a run of injuries.

Nothing official yet, I imagine GWS are probably going to try to hold him for a useful pick (40’s) given multiple teams want him.

He rucked a bit in earlier years but Brisbane added a bunch of young rucks and he played pretty much the whole time forward in 2023. Only had double digit hit outs once. He just isn’t a natural with using his body in a physical way but he is athletic.

Not holding my breath but there’s a role for him in a team that can really move the ball to just lead hard at the kicker across half forward. The Chol role at Hawthorn.

Being sympathetic is the least the Eagles could do given they dragged him across the country in prelim week.

Contracted until the end of next year and no signs that he’s unhappy. I expect over summer he’ll sign an extension until free agency Ie, 2029. We should make him an offer (both now and for post 2025), the same as the Saints and half the other Melbourne clubs should. Doubt he’ll be interested though. I can’t imagine there’s anyway GWS would trade him short of a stupid offer Ie. Pick 5, future first, steak knives and whilst he’s very good I don’t think that’s a wise deal.

I agree, but Bedford seems to be their number 1 tagger and they’ve slowly upped Callaghan’s midfield minutes as he starts to win his own footy. Daniels is starting to play more midfield too. They might be prepared to sell Peatling at his peak value right now knowing Harry Rowston, James Leake, Conor Stone and others are all ready to come in.

Going to assume Langford and O’Sullivan are gone by 5/6. 5. Murphy Reid 6. Sam Lalor 8. Draper 9. Armstrong 10. Tauru 11. Travaglia 15. Hotton 18. Lindsay 22. Faull Thats probably my list and the order is about right, just can’t decide whether I’m in or out on Reid yet.

Not sure Spargo will ever be a viable wing with his zero overhead game, but Chandler took some rotations in the last 2 weeks and looked fine. We need to do what every other club does and realise the wing is largely a trash position and stop spending so much on it and rotate guys through. Chander, Fritsch, Tholstrup should all play some minutes there, heck even Disco if he has a big summer and that way Windsor and Langdon can move around.