DeeZee

Does the panel think we are a genuine top 4 contender still? It’s looking more and more to me that we are lacking depth and have too many inconsistencies in our game to be truly considered a threat this year. We also seem to have no answer when Max is targeted by the opposition and in turn why do we hardly ever tag a major midfield ball winner such as Reid this week and Walsh last week?

Losing Gus, Harmes and Jordon means we have no depth in the midfield and have actually gone backwards with guys like Billing’s . Sparrow is no A grader either, and as much as we hate hearing it the forward line is always a work in progress, but now it’s getting too late to fix. But it’s the lack of intensity that really worries me, we just don’t seem to have that hunger we displayed three years ago.

Viney and Oliver aren’t as good as they once were Max is getting too old now and we have no forwards. Premiership window officially closed.

We have become embarrassing as a side. i don’t care if we beat StKilda next week now, we would have to win the next four in a row for me to have any more faith in this team. Is Viney playing?

We basically have no wings tonight, Langdon out and Windsor having a shocker

I’m sorry but billing’s is a spud

Sparrow is a liability, we need a decent tagger. Reid is doing as he pleases

I wish Pavlich would shut up about Narm being unsustainable

Gee remember that team we had in 21that was bursting with energy and excitement. The 24 Dee’s look slow, lack intensity and are just plain lazy.

I don’t know what’s happened to us but we are definitely no premiership threat.

I really don’t rate Sparrow or Bilings

Poor first quarter again, same as last week

Oliver is nowhere near it atm

If they don’t pick Verral they may pick Thommo to take TMacs role and put TMac up forward and ruck Ben Brown in for Turner If they do decide to rest Windsor for a game , it could be this week and bring Hunter in. They might give Salem one more week too , rather than risk a long flight. Koltyn and Mc Adam possible smokies

The lack of intensity in the first quarters of the Carlton and Brisbane games are worrying factors for me. You'd think they’d be super pumped for these big games. Were were switched on against the cats, but way off it against Blues and Lions.

Petracca 6 May 5 ANB 4 Viney 3 Langdon 2 Gawn 1

I just don’t think we cope well under intense pressure. When the opposition decide they are going to tackle and smother us with high intensity we have no answer until they run out of gas from their efforts. Brisbane did it to us and now Carlton.

We still have massive problems at centre bounce , we look all at sea far too often

We just don’t have an in form midfielder unfortunately

Absolute gun, very well deserved.

So good to see Petty hit some form . Some of those marks were huge. Got great elevation and really clunked them.

Pretty special first year player on our hands here. Loves the contest too.

6. Lever 5. Max 4. May 3. Windsor 2. Kozzie 1. Petty

Lobby would have to be one of the most useless big men Ive seen for all the size and physical attributes he has.

Don’t mind Pavlich, jack Riewoldt and Dicko as commentators.only Brereton spoils tonight’s commentary team