He hasn't been the worst, but his kicking and decision making is deplorable. I like him though. Good trier. Keep him.
It seems ridiculous to be talking delisting/trades already, but this is a particularly rare case and less about knee jerk reactions.
I'm not sure what the fallout of this will be. I cannot remember a worse performance. This reminds me of 186. Arguably worse, because at least Geelong are a good side.
Yes, okay. You keep saying this, but it's also the [censored] players that have to implement the basics of AFL, like accountability. Grimes, Garland, Rivers, Frawley and Clark are the only ones actually trying. Literally, 15 guys are not trying.
Yep. Neither. Cook should play forward. McDonald should be playing down back. Why stuff around with what is working? McDonald isn't a great kick. Cook is a beautiful kick generally, just hasn't earned a game yet.
Sorry, w
Not necessarily against going after Chapman or Foley for that matter, but Fisher? Our backs are about the only settled line on the list. Experienced midfielders with leadership, pacey outside mids with good foot skills, a small forward and probably another KP forward (wouldn't say no to Cloke).
Gysberts, Strauss and probably Martin are the only three that I'd include ahead of players on that list. I'd love to see Couch get a game in a few weeks too.
Not that I disagree with Scott, but the Roos have had a mini rivilary with us for the past 3 or 4 years, based on our young lists. He'd really enjoy sticking it in at the moment. Another in the media to do so at the moment. I think we'll surpass the Roos in a year or two though. Call it arrogant. Call it blind faith. Our list has far more upside than the Kangaroos.
There are hotter players out there than the Collingwood midfield (excluding Pendles and Swan). I say it every day, but I'd go after Sewell or Mitchell. What's Buddy's contractual situation like? Even though he's got a minder and on two strikes drugwise, since this is all pretty fanciful, I'd try and poach one of those older Hawk midfielders and offer Buddy a massive Judd-like six year deal.