praha

Disagree. You're asking Oliver to change his game plan based on our deficiencies. He is an inside player with unbelievable hands. Holding him to account because coaching and recruiting can't see we don't have outside skill and run is silly. He's Neither a catalyst nor a symptom of the problem. He's part of the solution. We're eating our own here by attacking Oliver.

You know what's sad? The best, most direct kick to a lead last night came from Frost to Petracca in the third quarter. Frost drilled it down Trac's throat and he fluffed it. They went down the other end and kicked a goal. Such is life.

We have a strong list that lacks depth, no doubt. Our major ball winners haven't played 100 games yet. This decade? Seeing as those only this season to go, Id agree.

I think the key atm is that we're playing bad football for a good side, rather than being a bad side playing bad football. It is quite obvious to me, that. We win the ball a lot and undoubtedly have the talent, but this is a funk. If we get to rounds 11-12 and we've won less than 4 games, the season can't be salvaged and at that point you start putting players on ice and blooding newbies. Then you reasses and reboot for 2020. I think a slow start and potential bottom 10 was completely viable and rational prediction for this team for this team. They look absolutely drained and still very much in pre season mode. I would reasses Goodwin's position mid-2020. Yes it is tough as supporters to be patient but you need to treat each year and regime in isolation. It is not ideal but top 4 and flag predictions were just hyperbole from the start. It creates a story if they don't perform. "What a disappointment!" Gary Pert has been around for 2 seconds. Anyone suggesting he is in a position to be vocal or held accountable is just being unreasonable. I'd give the current regime until mid 2020. That'll have Goodwin deep into year 4. From there if it's proven he's not right, then you look to Pert. Atm as a fanbase we need to think far more logically about this all. IMO this is my objective interpretation of our list, I think it's far more likely we'll bounce back than won't.

lost the game there. itnis demoralising.

it's pretty embarrassing. only melbourne could run through a banner with mean tweets, and then lose. like, it's the perform storm of stupid.

Averaging 114 points against this season. That is bottom of the ladder caliber.

Shaun Mckernan has 4 goals.

This team doesn't fight back and win from these positions. Don't think it's happened once under Goodwin. It'll either be a tussle, but we won't score. Or we will kick 5 goals from 20 inside 50s. And they'll kick 6 from 8. Bookmark it.

7 goals from 12 inside 50s. This is a common stat under Goodwin.

Two turnig points: ANB dropping an uncontested mark. And Captain Viney passing up having a shot on goal to stem momentum. Frost and O Mcdonald are not AFL footballers.

How do you get outmuscled by a guy that's 30kg? FMD, Frost. Also, microscope needs to be put on players that drop uncontested marks. Since ANB fumbled that, they have controlled us. It is demoralising.

Front on contact. The rules are as clear as day.

Hi everyone I left. What's the score.

Well we have our first Kent Kingsley Award For Spuds That Play Well Against Melbourne nominee.

This is a coaching effort at this stage. Winning too much of the ball and far too inefficient. Structurally and defensively we are pathetic. Two prime time night matches in the first three weeks of the season and we're playing the worst football in the league.

for any other coach this start to the year would be sackable. This is [censored] putrid.

They've had 7 scoring shots kicking against a 5-6 goal breeze. This is going to be a 10 goal loss.

We're bad but umpires are the main ones controlling momentum atm. Essendon a 6-7 goal better team atm.

We're horrible.

Three inside 50s. 2.1 for Essendon. We are 1 shot from 8 entries. Pathetic.

Sorry.

Good point re. Goodwin. His confidence and trust in the team is comforting.

We play finals for the first time in a decade and you want to put a coach's worth down to a single game?

Just what we need. More shanks going forward.