Jump to content

whatwhat say what

Life Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by whatwhat say what

  1. swans don't need a swathe of picks - they're like us in that they're in the 'win now' phase of their life hence mckay, grundy, etc.
  2. i believe he only got delisted as the afl rule at the time was you had to take three 'live' picks into a national draft? in a choice between him and sparrow for the 'next man up' midfield role in our afl side, i'm choosing sparrow good luck to him; be interesting to see if he can be more than a role player elsewhere
  3. hawkins could play for another five years but he'll never leave the cats
  4. jon ralph writes 350 words designed to get people to click it and read it before they go 'there's nothing to this article'
  5. think mick is pretty happy as a senior coach of a premiership winning, currently undefeated aflw side
  6. if north get pick 2 for being ordinary, pick 3 for mckay signing a mega-deal elsewhere, sanders as an nga for free AND a mid first round pick for being ordinary...it would be one of the greatest daylight robberies of all time
  7. love it when 31 post recent joiners come up with something as stupid as this so early in their demonland posting history kudos to you
  8. mindless speculation designed for clicks
  9. would happily have dew if yze gets the tigs job
  10. tomlinson would be worth nothing in a trade other than getting his $5-600k a year off our books for a year we're already going to jettison grundy's $650k for a negligible pick to the bloods he's vfl depth
  11. jesus wept, if we keep tomlinson and lose petty i'll be ropeable - i expect it's more about having someone with some senior experience available as vfl depth if one of may or lever are missing any football in 2024 directly responsible for at least 3, mebbe 4 goals in a game we lost by 2 points may spent more time having to tell him off about his positioning in the d50 than he did maintaining the zone
  12. mabior chol, you mean? if he makes our afl side's forward 5 in 2024 then we're either bit by the injury bug, again, or we're destined for somewhere between 5-10 on the ladder
  13. clearly touched; non-story
  14. our entire game plan is built around our defensive structure, which is based upon smart decision makers down back - may, lever, petty (although he may move forward permanently, replaced by disco turner), salem, mcvee, rivers, bowey while i think there's merit in the latter two moving into the midfield, who is replacing them? it's hard enough when you pull one jenga piece - e.g. petty - out, let alone one or two more
  15. we're in the 'win now' phase of our current list build; the notion of trading salem or langdon is absurd we don't need to replace our experienced players - particularly those like salem who are theoretically our most skilled players by foot - with speculative draft picks
  16. damn, missed the cut off... would have gone 6: hanks 5: hore 4: pearce 3: gay 2: mithen 1: mcnamara
  17. he's as slow and as poor a decision maker as tomlinson having watched may gesticulate madly about tommo's positioning to tommo on friday night we'd be sending steven to an early retirement if we picked up dougal
  18. presuming yze gets the tigs job, dew would be a good replacement we definitely need a change to bring in new voices and ideas - yze and stafford have been part of the set-up since preseason 2021 while chaplin has been at the club in various roles since 2016 time for a refresh
  19. front page of big footy:
  20. it's amazing that jesse hogan is about to be 29 at the start of next season it feels like just yesterday i was putting all my hopes and dreams into his 16 year old self
  21. maggots getting the pear back into it
  22. charlie dixon has a brand new tattoo gross
  23. toby bedford running into an open goal with jesse hogan free in the square...misses mfcss writ large right thurrr
  24. think it was the even dumber one, andrew