H_T

The Polls View: Bucks is highly respected going by peoples opinions.....

There you go Dark Horse72..........Schwab didn't inherit it, he had the blood on his hands - which is why we were in the red

There is your answer.

Grrrrrr. Missed the boat I'm afraid. :angry: Blame the voters.

Yes. Rivers does remain a bit of a concern. Fingers crossed he doesn't get injured again, gotta feel for him, he'd be feeling very frustrated.

Fair enough. Whats your opinion on Frawley then? Or I will re-phrase who do you rate more?

Doggo.....you must of loved that chase down on the Shermanator!

Your welcome.

Interesting vision.... Cameron Bruce couldn't make it?

Is that side the most inexperienced in the history of our club the mfc to take the field?

Not getting carried away, just making a wish with my packet of Tim Tams............

I'll remember that next time at the casino! You sure Schwab inherited the salary cap debacle? Didn't he oversee the whole drama on his watch!

R.Warock is a ruckman. M.Warnock a defender. Wheatley struggles against the bigger forwards for strength, so plays more on a wing or half back flank.

4 emergencies? No Robertson, No Grimes, No Buckley?

So you would get rid of M.Warnock because his brother may join the Dees? Ay curumba!

Whilst its not to be sneezed at, and he may have had the sleeves rolled up, in a 2 team town with AFL support, any of the CEO's in the AFL could of gone their and achieved a 2nd foothold in a two team town. Its easier to sell an alternative to the Eagles if you don't support the Eagles. Than it is in a 10 team town like Melbourne.

Not the Loin Chops! More contemporary?

Just doesn't possess a leap, that's all. He needs to be able to take a contested overhead pack mark for me....to be a CHF, FF....... ....Maybe I'm asking for too much!

Ok, who would you replace him for, as I asked earlier in the thread..........

Exactly - mud slinging, perhaps........wait and see

I sense a hint of sarcasm when you say it really doesn't matter because its more of a team for the future. Its been well highlighted numerous times when nominations opened in each category that it was for the best defenders, etc for the start of the 2009 season....you may have 'failed' to browse the thread on those occassions. B)

Not my side. Its collectively everyones side. Valenti happened to poll enough votes to make the cut.

The team has been extremely disappointing over the last two years.

Do we?

Whelan is considered a required player. Why some people are suggesting Martin and Warnock to be dropped, I'm not sure why. They should be given more game time and chances to prove themselves before the season finishes as Bailey pulls there strings to get more improvement. With someone like Carroll - you know what your going to get. Ie. Bailey has seen him from an oppositions point of view, and first hand with the 1st half of this year. He is contracted for 2009. As has already been stated. If Jmac is ready to go, he can come in for someone who Bailey feels needs more work on at Sandy. Until selection we won't know exactly who that is.