Redleg

You obviously didn’t see the pre season game this year where he got injured in the last minute. He was BOG by a mile. He has also played some good footy for us last year. That’s a pretty good start to see a boy with a good future. I guarantee the FD sees him as a regular best 23 player.

33 before the season starts and 192 cms is not what we need imo. I would want younger and bigger as a key forward. I would rather go with Kentfield if we can’t get younger and bigger.

Sorry, my error then.

I don’t see how we are that far off, when we win 7, lose another 9 by under two goals and run one of the flag favourites to 1 point and 6 points in two games.

He is certainly not unprepared, on the way I have heard him answer questions, in the interviews I have heard so far. He actually sounds very prepared and there is not an er, um, ah in any answer, nor does he give the old chestnut of many interviewees, “ I will get back to you on that“

Once again we are attacking a current player and denigrating him because he might leave. This is not specifically aimed at you, but rather posters generally. It’s ok to post you don’t think someone will make it, but do we really need to ridicule our players?

It was a lot longer than that we raised it with him, as reported. He has had months. This is the excuse to save face and then accept Tassie.

There is some talk about Suns chasing Curnow. If that happens we can forget Flanders.

Isn’t it funny when they want another club’s player, the language is so different from when they want to keep their own player?

I think the real issue is when you trade up and give away a lot to get a certain player, you need to actually get that player and then he has to be worthy of what you gave up. As recent examples, Lindsay looks the goods, while Kolt is looking a little shaky. To be a successful club we need to nail most decisions and recruiting is an extremely important area for every club. I do accept that not every selected player will have a long AFL career but the overall aim has to be improving the list every year.

He can finish the Cats season while still working on MFC issues behind the scene, just as Guerra did. Mitchell does recruiting while preparing the Hawks for their finals.

This mystery should be put to bed pretty soon.

Had a good first half.

Fogarty has had two shockers.

Not every employee is good at their job. I think this year alone I have heard him get about 10 things wrong. Then the pearler, he said Mason Cox was in the best 3 ruckmen in the AFL. That is about the most stupid comment of any media person I have heard this year.

Articulate and clearly across the topics raised. Impressive so far.

The Crows need Merrett more than the Hawks. They should have a go at him and he would get his finals team wish and get out of Melbourne and avoid some heat as well.

I believe Kingy loves a banana smoothie, he is our type of coach.

Most do it at the exit meeting.

Ryan will be about $700K-$800k, that is significant. Wilkie on $800k has been offered more elsewhere and has asked Saints to match. King on $1.2m. Sinclair has to be $800k. I am told Steele on about $1m. Owens $800k. Wood $600k-700k. There are plenty of others on decent money. They will have to offload players or the rest will be on $50k.

Ticked off by head office like Scott, Stengle, Bruhn, audit and everything else.

From around the traps and looking logically, when Graham Wright had that discussion with Bucks at Collingwood which led to his “ resigning “ , it was likely because as with most ex coaches, he had lost the players, Bucks even said the message had become stale and a new voice was needed. Sound familiar? Until I see firm evidence to the contrary though, I believe Bucks had the job, the AFL came hard with a massive offer and Bucks accepted it and then gave answers that basically eliminated him. Saying you are seeing another club and won’t commit until after that meeting would eliminate any candidate. Anyone want to predict Bucks won’t be Coach of Tassie now? The yachts are sailing up the Derwent as someone posted. Bucks will be announced as Tassie Coach without a process in the next few months. Maybe we got the better Coach, hopefully that is the case. I just hope the AFL is compensating us for what I perceive as their interference in our process. Candidates withdrew because they believed Bucks had the job. Sure it is the Tassie consortium, but we know who is behind them,

You can't win finals without a midfield.

Is there a more dispisable player in the game than Ginnivan? Can’t stand him.

I would actually reduce his options to two. Stay or go.