dee-tox

Joeboy your assessment of Melksham, Fritsch and Garlett makes me wonder if I saw the same game at all. Melksham and Garlett were amazing at times while Fritta was ordinary for the second week in a row. Maybe carrying an injury.

6. Melksham 5. Oliver 4. Brayshaw 3. Frost 2. Jeffy 1. Lewis.

Some good: Frost, Jeffy, TMac, Lewis Plenty bad: OMac, Smith, Hogan, Jones.

OMac is an absolute liability.

Comparisons are odious! This team can do it but needs to realise what it takes. Develop a ruthless streak and a hate for losing that ensures Saturday night never happens again.

We need guys that can run hard all day and dispose of the pill. The best in the league at the moment are Gaff and Whitfield. Given Gaff is a potential free agent we need to go hard. Hawthorn outsmarted us this year by not getting first possession and sitting back waiting for the likes of ANB, Bugg and Tyson to turn it over. We need quality ball carriers!

Correct. And ANB fumbled all night.

Too late in the season to blood Keilty. So Oscar stays unfortunately. JKH is gone. Shame his best games were in his debut year five years ago.

Jones a 4 is a joke. Oscar and JKH scores are fair. Our bottom six are NQR.

6. Oliver 5. Petracca 4. TMac 3. Jones 2. Harmes 1. Gawn.

It hurts. Some huge lessons required. You don't give up a six goal lead. Smith not killing the pill. Midfield stopped half way through. Terrible miss by JKH in last. Simple snap from 25. Oscar was pathetic for much of the night.

Superb football Dee's. Keep running. Great quarter by Petracca, Salem, Bernie...

Plenty of good signs. Jesse, clarry, TMac, Jeffy looking dangerous. Don't like the fumbles from ANB, Fritta and missing simple shots. Just an aside James Brayshaw's commentary is excellent!

I will half believe!

I'd play him! Hannan was poor for much of last week and JKH plays like a frightened rabbit. Bugg is capable of being a link in the chain like he was against North kicking four goals. He can run and mark overhead. His problem is he turns it over by foot and isn't a particularly strong tackler.

Think Hannan will be in trouble. Was very poor for much of yesterday. Wonder if Bugg will ever reappear?

Majority of posters gave Salem votes for good reason. You rated him lower than Frost, Hibberd, Lewis, who many considered putrid.

Picked up some cheapies in the last. Looks a long way away, unfortunately.

Good second half. The cream rose to the top. First half some of our battlers were really exposed. Hannan, JKH, Frost, etc. Hibberd not half the player he was last year. Lewis kept falling over. Lost too many one-on-ones. Atrocious kicking at times. I'm still not sure about this side!

6. Gawn 5. Brayshaw 4. Oliver 3. Salem 2. Hogan 1. TMac

The opposition was pretty ordinary to be fair.

Smith has to go. So far away from it. Goodwin will stick with ANB, but perhaps shouldn't.

6. Salem 5. Brayshaw 4. Oliver 3. Gawn 2. Petracca 1. Viney

Vince and Spargo out. Unsure who in? Jeffy?

The falling over and the slowness are a worry. Our oldest Vince and Lewis were exposed. Our youngest in Spargo was also exposed.