Bowserpower

No shock there Top-tier coach who everyone wants

Sad what happened to him Will be hard to come back from this kind of injury. The club wouldn't have known the future.

I like it.

Do it respectfully, not to win popularity contests.

You tend to make these kinds of comments a lot and time them so they get the reactions but never add anything of substance to the discussion and put others down for simply having an opinion. I've seen it multiple times now. . I know this won't be popular as this place is popularity driven rather than merit but if you don't like others opinions then don't read.

Just because we blew our picks in it doesn't mean it was terrible.

Don't just troll @john delosa. At least people have the guts to put their opinions forward.

Get out

Think you're off your rocker mate. Another reason people don't take you seriously.

I think what list managers and fans think is a fair trade are 2 very different things.

Are people happy with another year like we got from him this year. Wasn't bad but wasn't going to win you a premiership. I would like a little more in a trade but beggars can't be choosers. It isn't a terrible offer

We would need to find someone somewhere. Another Turner type would be handy. The draft is shallow though.

It's also rich and surprising to see so many people rejecting two first round picks out of hand. Think the MFC goggles on.

Flanders would be a great get.

I'll have what you're smoking. You're in lalaland if you think we get pick 5 for Petracca...

Disagree. If the player wants out again then cut the trade and move on.

Can we please keep the conversation about the new coach?

I don't trust Caroline Wilson as far as I could kick her

This has to be a joke.

We'll lose Kalani now. Why would he want to leave his backyard and miss out on playing for a team on the up.

Pathetic if this were the case.

That is true. I tried running the exercise but it wasn't easy. Geelong with Ablett Collingwood with Grundy West Coast with Judd Melbourne with Hogan

The coach should be the buck stopper

We need to get rid of one of them, no question about it. Between the two, I’d probably keep Petracca because he clearly has more upside and can still turn games around when he’s on. He’s shown glimpses of brilliance, and there’s still some to tap into. Oliver has been seriously underwhelming. He hasn’t been close to the level we expect from him—not even remotely. His form has been crap, no question about it and he’s just not contributing in the way he should be. Honestly, I’d even be willing to pay a portion of his salary just to get him off the books and onto another team. It’s harsh, but we can’t afford to carry passengers if we want to move forward., and he’s just not contributing in the way he should be.

Alright, let us know how you go mate