GawnWithTheWind

Vickery out is more of a win for them then us!

If all is true does that mean outs for them include: Martin - Connors - King - Grimes - Jackson If only Clark was playing..................

Haha righto. That is an easy response, explain why I am wrong?

Apologies

I'm wide awake, same as Dusty at tramp at 7am on sundays... I'm saying I am happy with the trenners call at 2 now instead of dusty who is [snip] most weekends.. while trenners is leading the oldest club in the land.

No idea...

Happy we didnt take Dusty now! Connors in trouble

I disagree. Deledio sets up all of their run and attack. If McKenzie can shut him down (similar to goddard) then we are a bigger chance for mine. Cotchin is a star, but we have to put someone like Bail or Grimes to run with and shut down.

Ins: Jones, Jamar, Cook, Petterd (needs a chance to prove himself) Outs: Bate, Spencer, McDonald, Magner FB: Joel Mac - Frawley - Nicho HB: Tapscott - Sellar - Watts C; Grimes - Moloney - Trengove HF: Howe - Cook - Petterd FF: Garland - Sylvia - Martin R: Jamar - Jones - McKenzie I: Bail, Blease, RIvers S: Dunn Match Ups: Frawley - Riewoldt McKenzie - Deledio Sellar - Miller Tapscott - Edwards Nicho - Nahas

Wow we are bad.. Worst list in the comp?

And yet you defend Bate.

If it was me: Ins: Tapscott Out: Clark FB: Sellar (Merrett) - Frawley (Brown) - MacDonald HB: Nicho - Tom Mac - Watts C: Jones - Moloney - Howe HF: Sylvia - Rivers - Dunn FF: Davey - Garland - Magner R: J-man - Trengove - Grimes I: Blease - McKenzie - Bate S: Tapscott Ugly lineup...

sigh..........

Well maybe this is a problem in itself. One thing you can say about Dunn is he seems to give his 100% when he is out there. That chase down when the game was already cooked was very impressive. ALOT of other melbourne players would have given up. I'd drop ALOT of other players before outting him.

Why is everyone dropping Dunn. He is one of our better contested marks (not high flying, but good positioning) and one of our better users by foot. I think gets too much criticism and would be in my 22 each week. Plus is an avenue to goal, which we will need due to Clarks absence

Pretty sad actually

Trent croad

I cant comprehend this crap.. Anything decent this club gets, something happens.. Could you ask for a worse year? End the season now

Stuff Cloke and Boak. Lets go after Beams, Wellingham or Goldsack. Id be happy for MFC to pay them a bit to get them into the red n blue. Wellingham and Beams are tough mids, but can play outside and Goldsack would be very, very handy in any side.

I think Boak is overrated. We need someone with polish to add to our mid. If he comes back to Vic, he will go to the cats.

Ahhh yes! Cheers

Anyone got a link to buy a ticket to this pre-match function?

"I don't think Melbourne will like to be dancing with us," Sheedy said. "We've already taken Scully off them - so it's not going to be the loveliest day down at the MCG." Geez, this a must win game just for the pride of our football club.

Ins: Cook - Davey - Couch Outs: Tapscott (suspended) - Magner (rest) - Trengove (rest) Cook deserves a chance, and would play on a similar aged defender. Davey can shred apart lesser teams, and apparently has been doing everything right in casey (from what I hear) Magner needs a rest and Trenners could do with a 2 week break. One more good performance for Stef and Barty needs to get his body right first. FB: Garland - Frawley - McDonald HB: Nicholson - Rivers - Watts C: Blease - Jones - Grimes HF: Sylvia - Cook - Howe FF: Davey - Clark - Dunn R: J-man - Moloney - McKenzie I: Sellar - Couch - Morton S: Green

Trengove - obviously carrying injuries Grimes - had a crack Jones - showing the way Watts - learning the craft Frawley - good shutdown role Morton - some ok things Clark - serious man crush Sylvia - at cross roads Mckenzie - does his job Dunn - needs more gametime Blease - shows some brilliance Green - feel for him Garland - needed down back Moloney - release the beast!!! McDonald - continues decent season Rivers - forgot to change ends Seller - has a crack Tapscott - loved every minute Howe - needed more help Jamar - hit out king Nicholson - showing some signs Magner - needs a rest