old55

McCartney used to say to the effect "when you're watching on TV and you see more Demons than on the screen than opposition you know we're going well and are going to win" - I think we've changed tack in the intervening period.

You seem confused kev. You're the champion of free speech except when @Deefiant and @rpfc exercise their rights to it

Is Weideman the right guy?

Last Friday's outcome with Weid was 2 goals kicked directly by players that he handballed to after groundball gets under maximum pressure. That's rare stuff from KPFs 2 goals kicked directly after marking contests that he got first hands to There were also 2 goals he would normally have kicked from marks but his kicking was a bit off - normally he is a beautiful kick and there is not a structural issue with his kicking. He also got his hands to a number of marks that just didn't stick - he did stick his last mark at full stretch but couldn't finish with the kick at goal Two Fwd 50 tackles that resulted in stoppages That's decent output and, if he takes all his chances, it's dominant output.

I don't think the FD rate him whereas they do rate Bowey. Also I think Bowey is more like for like dor Salem with his kicking skills.

I see the core of our 28-29 flag sides: Petty, Rivers, Bowey, Jackson, Oliver, Jordon, Sparrow, Weid, Spargo, Kossie.

Langdon for Melksham who only played 57% gametime. Maybe Bowey to give Salem, who looks proppy, 2 weeks off. Weid to stay.

Watched that last quarter goal-fest in the west from Essendon and Richmond where just about every i50 resulted in a goal. That's just not going to happen against us.

They're a very talented well-drilled side at virtually full strength. That win was absolute ripper.

We had 8 players with less than 50 games vs 5 for them.

Quite frankly it was fine, I knew we could play much better than we were and the fact that the difference only got out to 20 points despite the fact that they were at full strength and could not possibly play any better was a positive.

It absolutely is when it's about events over which you have absolutely no control except how you feel about them

Raised by @Hannibal on BF - "young Lions" is a myth: Average Attributes Melbourne Attribute Brisbane 188.0cm Height 187.9cm 86.5kg Weight 87.0kg 24yr 9mth Age 26yr 2mth 88.9 Games 111.8

Weid had another "almost" game, he's still not quite sticking his marks and his kicking confidence is down. Two aerial contest led to goals and groundball gets and handballs directly produced two goals. He also tackled with intent. He's 23 and he has all the attributes, he just needs to stitch it together. He'll play next week against Collingwood and he needs to continue to compete hard to maintain his place - another "almost game" and VFL resumption over the bye giving BB a chance to assert himself may see Weid out against Essendon. He's a work in progress and the forward line is functioning very productively with him in there.

YES!

Just avoid game day thread.

So Brisbane averaging 107 and us averaging 62 against. That's a big difference.

Who is in their top 3 they refer to? I don't expect Neale to play. Zorko, McCluggage ??? I strongly prefer Petracca and Oliver.

None of that is too unreasonable. I prefer it when opposition supporters are feral flogs ...

Maybe Carlton could have benefitted from your insight before the last trade period?

https://www.melbournefc.com.au/albums/946531/western-bulldogs-v-melbourne-afl-round-11-2021?modal=true&type=gallery&playlistId=946531&playlistSize=111 Images 21, 46 and 49 and 111 seem to suggest otherwise.

I'm very fortunate that lockdown is only inconvenient for me - unlike for many whose livelihoods are affected or have kids in home schooling but ... On my morning exercise walk 1/3rd of people not wearing masks. We have 2 Covid sites in the neighbourhood but about 20 people assembled outside the local cafe waiting for their take-away coffee - chatting, half a metre apart - no masks. Multiply by a thousand Melbourne-wide. Selfish, thoughtless people who think they are special and the rules don't apply to them. This is a big reason why there is lockdown and extended lockdown. Don't get me started on unvaccinated aged care workers - what they're thinking beggars belief.

TBF I don't know anything in detail about the talent either but there's just not going to be flag ready to go KPs out there.

I'd walk there if necessary ...

Any ready-to-go player will be a role player not a pea. Even Marlion Pickett, the most successful MSD, is a role player, notwithstanding his GF heroics - I could have got a kick against GWS that day. @Cheesy D. Pun - I think we've got cover for injuries to 2 KPs - of course we'll be weakened and it depends who they are how much that would be - any two of May, Lever and TMac is going to really hurt. But the point is there's just not going to be greater ready-to-go talent out there than Majak and M.Brown. Just to be clear - I wouldn't play either Brown back - TMac and Majak would be first choices to move there and we'd plug the forward gap.