Ferghus31

The Problem is Goodwin he wont listen to others is pig headed makes huge errors during games he Needs to go

If Adam gets the Tigers gig i would replace him with Trent Cotchin and Daisy Pearce make them responsible for Midfield and onballers get Stewart Dew as Forward Coach make Mark Stinnear our Assistant coach i am very impressed with him he has an amazing ability to read the game unlike Goodwin he listens to others . Finally lure Phil Davis for backline all of these replace all other Coaches except Williams

Make Smith the Sub and add JJ

Totally Agree but Goodwin does not look at history and doesnt take risks all season our forwards were the problem except when Petty and Melk applied defensive Pressure he is the problem for not fixing this also our assistant coaches incl Choco should demand fixing before its too LATE

Goodwin will have to be forced into playing Grundy he doesnt like change and will resist it he should have realized earlier Max cannot do it on his own and played Grundy against Collingwood just like his idea of a Forward Line he wont admit that he was wrong i blame him entirely

Fully agree a very decent person and Fair Footballer HE HAS A GREAT FUTURE outside of football also laughs at himself and of course Max Get better hopefully all up and about for the G Final hope its against Collingwood would, be great if he does make it and he kicks the winning Goal

Moyle can really play just needs to get fitter a very good mark and kick and very strong an excellent prospect grab him and Chol

As I previously stated we should demand Amati plus their first draft pick if Brodie requests a transfer discussed BUT AGAIN has Grundy STATED HE WANTS TO LEAVE No? I rest my case

I partly agree with this side but no to Turner Spargo Make Smith the Sub keep Chandler and recall Grundy Jordon Schache as a Defensive Forward on Weithering outs Tommy Mac Angus Van Rooyen Play Bowey on the Ball and Replace Goodwin with our AFLW Coach he listens to his assistants and has flare and daring

Sydneys Armati will be offered to us for Grundy and our 3 Selection suits me as we have a young Ruck Backup and potential Forward i was told this by my friend that works for a Player Manager

He would be my First out has cost us several games with lack of Skill and Concentration needs to Find Form at VFL MY OTHER OUTS ARE Spargo replace with Bowie Neil Bullen replace with Angus Brayshaw as Forward Defender Smith as Sub and Baille Laurie all Elite with Foot kicking Skills Max to Full Forward

I dont think anyone has taken into account that other Teams have Improved with Skilfull Players we havent the number of times we take the wrong options no talking when contesting notibly Forward 4 examples ANBx2 Harmes x1 Spargox1 missed certain goals they are fixable ANB gets found out Harmes has no confidence and Spargo is too quick thinking for his Mates also Van Royen leave him at CHB he the only Forward that can Turn apart from Fritch Backline Lever is having a horror Season needs to be a floater and find a CHB this will go a long way to balance their Strenghts the other problem is Tackling an the Backline. My Solution Drop Harmes ANB Mc Donald and bring in Pace and Skills Hunter Laurie Thomlonson play Rivers on ball and Brawshaw back to Half Forward Lastly change the Gameplan to an more Franatic style and confuse our opponents i bet this will work

I just returned from Perth on a Virgin Flight and met a well-known player manager and forward scout for the swans the player manager stated that Freo are waiting on Lobb to Decide to go to the Bulldogs they will have to give up plenty for Him that will open the way for Jackson if he decides to go Freo there has been no indication that he wants to leave also he has a big Knee Problem that requires an operation. Melbourne will want plenty maybe Young or Serong have been spoken about among the Managers one interesting point that was made is Jackson appears happy with Melbourne and the WCE have not indicated any Interest and are concerned that he has no Forward Craft. The Forward scout told me that Don Pyke of the Swans is a Brilliant Strategest and is the big reason for their improved Form he maybe the Coach of Essendon Also, he said Goodwin is very Conservative COACH and not daring the issue compared to other sides success in the Finals has been the enthusiasm that youth brings is infectious Melbourne needs to be daring The player Manager told me THERE WILL BE CHANGES AT THE END OF THE Year with coaches. Lastly what our strength the defense has become our weakness other sides realize that if the ball is below their knees they panic. I think we have blown it but still have firm belief in those proud leaders Max Clarry Viney May and Brayshaw that they may prevail

I would not drop Bowey makes the right decisions and better user of the Ball also tackles stick the unlucky one would be Nibbler he needs to work on his decision making with Ball in hand also gets caught make him earn his spot Back Bowey can play on Talls and Smalls the Swans have a very good group of Both

Out Neil Bullen for Harmes if BBB available Weid also I would liker to find a position For Bowey if Melk slips he is the one we must keep Angus in the Centre and instruct Sparrow to use the Ball Better he is a very good Player. I also observed that the Yank did Not shake Maxes hand after the LAST Game that should be some motivation to seek revenge

THE Summary of the 3 word is spot on But it is hard to play in a side that firstly has to counter elite disposal and organisation look again at the First Quarter we just Butchered the Ball and took wrong Options our new Players also need some time to Adjust to our style exception Picket and Langdon I would spend the next 8 weeks drilling the players on creating Space backing up another and use of the Ball BETTER one thing the West Coast Juicers have is a System we dont however we can BY just drilling it in to the players remember we had more use of the Ball I feel sorry for our Forwards but they too dont lead or organise correctly WCoast can be beaten if it becomes one on one . Next Game be Daring Play Weidman Jackson Jones and Salem ( all can Kick)and persist with them dont Play Tomlison on a Wing but down Back he could become elite with Lever and May play Petracca in the middle Oliver on a Flank Harmes as a tagger and Melksham as a defensive Forward Fritsch at FF