BDA

you just beat me to it @DeeSpencer

A Tassy team would be no different to any other team as regards retention. If they’re successful they’ll retain and if not then they struggle. The same argument could be said if the AFL were starting a team in Geelong now. All the youngsters want to leave, who would want to live in Geelong rah rah, whereas as in fact, Geelong is cited as a lifestyle choice, amongst its other selling points. Why can’t Tassy be the same? Hobart is a beautiful spot.

And another thing, the assumption that a flag at the Hawks has a lesser value than one he would have won at the Dees is bogus. A flag, is a flag, is a flag. Pretty sure Brian Lake wouldn’t swap his 3 peat with the Hawks for a flag at the Dogs.

Not saying that any D’lander is a hypocrite (God forbid), but in the interests of full disclosure and transparency I think we should all declare, before passing comment on chip, whether we have ever a) changed jobs in our life b) choose an option which resulted in a greater financial return to us c) choose an option which provided us with greater opportunity I tick all the above. He gave 7 good years of good service when we were a rabble, (the last year club and player had separated in spirit) and we got pick 3 when he left. Won his medallion at the Hawks and has now taken the option of an extra year at the saints. Are people seriously saying he should forego a years income, at a level that he’ll probably never be able to earn post career.

It’s a mystery to me why Tassy hasn’t been given a team yet. Its footy heartland. Participation rates are the canary in the goldmine. Ignore at your peril Gil. It would be a shocking dereliction of duty to ignore the base and lose Tassy while wasting time and resources on a vanity project in the Gold Coast. Btw this Godfrey bloke appears to be just the type of hard headed realist needed to head up a strategic review of the Suns.

The very public nature of his departure from the pies and the continuing wrangling over his salary can’t be doing Treloar’s confidence any good. It’ll be very interesting to see if he can settle back down and produce decent footy for the dogs in 2021. I won’t be surprised if he under-performs.

I think his kicking is fine. He’s had off days for sure like every player but broadly his stats match-up with his peers. It’s the double grabs that are the big knock on his game imv. Cut those out and he’ll be a real threat for us. I don’t think the MFC have done a good job developing Sam. KPF will have off days. It’s important to persist and Goodwin hasn’t done that dropping him after some bad games, not picking him at the start of this season, which has obviously dented his confidence. Sam has had runs of games where he has been very good so he definitely has the ability. This year he needs to be backed in. Told he and BB will be our spearheads. Sending him back to the 2’s serves no purpose anymore. Let’s see what he’s got this year with BB beside him. I think he’s got the goods and will deliver 40 odd goals for us. Over to you Sam.

For those who aren't bothered to read the story I’ll summarise it for you: The car started. Then he drove it away.

Legendary. Maradona level.

slow news day at fox footy

Best not egg him on!

Fair enough Axis. Good points well made. Still reckon less talk and more action is the way to go though.

Pickett, Rivers and LJ were developing nicely.

I think the question should be Why do we need footy calendars at all. The kids are into ipads these days so I think their day has passed. btw the Collingwood calendar is probably worse than Norths

Something along the lines we’ll let our footy do the talking when we take the field. Actions not words. I get he has to front the media and I get why some supporters don’t pay too much attention to these articles. Fair enough. For me I’ve heard it all before and it irritates me. Sorry, that just the way I feel about it.

sorry. please eggscuse my lame pun

If we do pick him up lets hope we're not left with egg on our face

It would have been best if you read my post in full and not strip out one comment and then interpret it out of context. I know he has media obligations. I know it’s a fluff piece Who said he needed to self-flagellate? The messaging could be different and still cater to the whole fanbase. Hearing the same thing each pre season without follow through makes the words had to swallow. That was my point which you’ve conveniently decided to by-pass.

Why do you say?

And cover TMac's salary which would be far in excess of what Chip will earn.

I'm an optimist by nature but I have my moments of doubt but I genuinely think we have a list now to break into the Top 4 and challenge.

I can’t wrap my head around the concept of switching allegiances like that. If Maxy, Trac , Oliver and May decided to de-camp, on mass, to a rival I still wouldn’t be for turning. Even if there was a time machine that took me back to the fateful time when I got hooked on the Dees I still wouldn’t change my decision. That said I do wonder whether I should inflict the Dees on my kids. It’s a hard road.

Fair point but I was being a little flippant. I thought it a strange comparison

They sure are interesting comparisons! I’ve just been put off Finlay Macrae because he’s been compared to David Zaharakis! Really hope this kid finds his way to us: Bailey Laurie Height: 179cm Weight: 78kg Weapon: High footy IQ Player comparison: Brent Daniels, GWS GIANTS Haven’t seen much discussion about Zac Reid in any threads (presumably will go before our picks). Just seen his highlights. Liked what i saw. I’d add composure to his weaponry. And the comparison to Harris Andrews! Could be the long-term replacement for S May? If we are looking at KPD then wouldn't be surprised if we moved up the order to select him. Zac Reid Height: 202cm Weight: 83kg Weapon: Overhead marking and absolute reach Player comparison: Harris Andrews, Brisbane

Because it was rushed. Gotta say the dogs look foolish here. You'd think salary split is the no. 1 item to get right in the deal and particularly given the circumstances around treloars contract.