Kent

Exactly Rusty He needs to be reviewed along with the whole sorry lot How long has he been there. Maybe he is a part of the problem.

I can only wish and hope and have faith. Nothing I have seen in the last 5 weeks tells me that things will change. But there you go. We are now having to be a faith based supporter group.

What's the use of sacking him mid season. Sack him now and give the new guy the off season and pre season to remake this shambles of a team.

He is right I wouldn't kick it to him either Anb is a serial miss kick Could kick 2 every game if he could learn to kick has been doing it the whole of his illustrious career

what pick was this guy in 2017? you have to be impressed in the WC Eagles drafting and player development They really have a gun recruiting group

I love the term list clogging Never used to but Melbourne have made it into an artform

You missed the great Collingwood Game Bitter From where I was it was unwatchable

Exactly Lord In fact it appears to me that the midfield is better without him playing Jack is not essential far from it.

If he is injured then DONT PLAY HIM

Again Sorry remind what Todd brings to the club . What is his actual job??

Trade him to CW for first rounder pick 14 easy peasy

Should join the gang of happy clappers and faith based commentators on here.

What does Todd Viney do actually?

Deservedly so in my opinion, but lets wait and see how the end of year plays out

I was actually talking about Goodwin and Maccas relationship. But take your point Bb.

How in hells' name can you tell?

They have a high performance high performance department?

Roughhead and Burgoyne talking with Suns Who are Melbourne talking to? Roughy to coach our forwards YES Please.

And why McCartny, who calls a spade a spade, was removed from the coaches box and then given the flick. Carp on that!

Looks like a stunned mullet in the box but you are right dont know him at all. Can I be allowed to judge him on his performance? Challenge all you like. You must know him very well if you know for sure he isn't stubborn.

Mate these people were hand picked byGoodwin and Mahoney We have trusted them and they have failed in all ways possible. I am not sure the best assistants and staff in the world would be able to help Goodwin.He is too stubborn and obviously out of his depth He is dead man walking in my view.Too difficult to come back from where he has put himself and the club. Put him and the supporters out of their collective misery. Nothing can really change between now and midseason 2020.

Can he coach?

Find it amazing earlier in the season many here and in media were questioning the competence of the Melbourne coaching staff and we were told all was ok, we have the right coaching team, the metrics are trending positively yah yah yah> No review necessary etc etc. Now all of a sudden we are having external review overseen by Mahoney and we are jettisoning coaches like no toomorrow. Has the football club finally woken up from their slumber? The whole year has been about spin and I for one am tired of it. We can handle the truth!!!

I bet they wish they hadn't prematurely re-signed him Nowhere to hide now Mr Pert and Mr Mahoney

There is so much going wrong in that picture it beggars belief. Frame it, put on the wall and tell every player every day that is not how you play modern footy Its a disgrace.