Rodney (Balls) Grinter

19 minutes ago, RedLegs23 said:

Terrible luck for Oscar. That looked nasty!

Yeah, really feeling for the bloke right now.

Hopefully it's not a long term injury.

What mixed fortunes for the McDonald brothers today.

Watching the Lions get beaten by Freo Vs watching the MFC replay ...hmmmm

See ya Lions!

16 minutes ago, leave it to deever said:

Dogs are a good side.

But I think that we can all agree that the Swans are very good.

Especially at home.

It was a good win in sweltering conditions.

With some key players back in form.

I'm excited enough.

As an asides, I actually think playing Rd 0 was an advantage to us.  Rd 1 teams are usually a little scratchy, but we had a proper game last week, not a practice match per the dogs and think we are that bit more match fit as a team compared to them.

Well at least that's what I told myself during the week after our loss to the Swans and I guess it transpired as such.

9 minutes ago, Rodney (Balls) Grinter said:

Yeah, Ralphy just showed it at half time of the Lions V Freo game.

Fair brain fade by Harmes.  Not that I think he would have got a game next week, but I think he'll be sitting one out in the cooler now, not even the mugoos

I should add that I use to have alot of respect for Harmes (and still love him deep down too), but also have more love and respect for May.

5 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

A reminder that was the first time our 2021 draft class have all played together in the one game.

Jason Taylor just doing his thing once again.

Sorry Daz, being a bit lazy, but which players are we talking here specifically?

4 minutes ago, chook fowler said:

Another under the radar but highly effective game by Nibbler. Gets little recognition but is a great contributor.

Love ANB.

Great call to play on and goal after he'd taken that mark too.

2 hours ago, Tracca said:

just saw it, harmes headbutted may. crazy!

Yeah, Ralphy just showed it at half time of the Lions V Freo game.

Fair brain fade by Harmes.  Not that I think he would have got a game next week, but I think he'll be sitting one out in the cooler now, not even the mugoos

33 minutes ago, In Harmes Way said:

Wasn’t it just nice to sit in the afternoon Sun and football? 

Instead of all our games being played on a Wednesday, Thursday, Friday or Saturday night - yes absolutely!

4 minutes ago, defuture15 said:

Balls, I think most of the Bill love comes from a game against geelong 2nds in the rain when casey had an incredible win.

It was a BOG for him.

He definately has ability

I've heard the lore of all these great VFL games he's played, but I'm sorry every time he plays at AFL level he looks scared and out of his depth.

25 minutes ago, Tracca said:

what qtr was this

Last qrt I think.  May was trying to point out something Harmes did to the umpires too, but they were being useless as always.

32 minutes ago, Cheap Seats said:

WHile i 100% agree with you, i am going to go out on a limb and say from a leadship POV i like what Goody did by rewarding players who displayed the values teh club wants.

Did the players take their opportunities, well taht is debatable, do I think they will make it, again debatable, but i do think it was good leadership.

Yeah, don't get that at all.  I hardly think I've see Laurie play a hard contested manner or with a defensive mindset.  In neither of the practice matches did he show any class and poise handling the ball that is suposely his one wood.  Look good on him if he goes on and proves me wrong, but from all I've seen, he's just not senior AFL standard.

We have plenty of other up and comming players like Wowewodin, Kynan Brown, Throstrup etc that are already ahead of him and don't see why we keep gifting him games or why we extended his contract.  Hope he's only getting paid peanuts.

Billings on the other hand had been great in both our practice matches.  Looks to be a really solid citizen off the field and would think he would have been oozing our club values.   I thought it was a huge mistake to play him starting as the sub last week.

30 minutes ago, Cheap Seats said:

WHile i 100% agree with you, i am going to go out on a limb and say from a leadship POV i like what Goody did by rewarding players who displayed the values teh club wants.

Did the players take their opportunities, well taht is debatable, do I think they will make it, again debatable, but i do think it was good leadership.

Yeah, don't get that at all.  I hardly think I've see Laurie play a hard contested manner or with a defensive mindset.  In neither of the practice matches did he show any class and poise handling the ball that is suposely his one wood.  Look good on him if he goes on and proves me wrong, but from all I've seen, he's just not senior AFL standard.

We have plenty of other up and comming players like Wowewodin, Kynan Brown, Throstrup etc that are already ahead of him and don't see why we keep gifting him games or why we extended his contract.  Hope he's only getting paid peanuts.

Billings on the other hand had been great in both our practice matches and I thought it was a huge mistake to play him starting as the sub last week.

27 minutes ago, Cheap Seats said:

WHile i 100% agree with you, i am going to go out on a limb and say from a leadship POV i like what Goody did by rewarding players who displayed the values teh club wants.

Did the players take their opportunities, well taht is debatable, do I think they will make it, again debatable, but i do think it was good leadership.

Yeah, don't get that at all.  I hardly think I've see Laurie play a hard contested manner or with a defensive mindset.  In neither of the practice matches did he show any class and poise handling the ball that is suposely his one wood.  Look good on him if he goes on and proves me wrong, but from all I've seen, he's just not senior AFL standard.

We have plenty of other up and comming players like Wowewodin, Kynan Brown, Throstrup etc that are already ahead of him and don't see why we keep gifting him games or why we extended his contract.  Hope he's only getting paid peanuts.

Billings on the other hand had been great in both our practice matches and I thought it was a huge mistake to play him starting as the sub last week.

1 hour ago, leave it to deever said:

The biggest take away for me was Bbbs performance.
Didn't kill it but a very good serviceable game nonetheless. Our best tall fwd.

He had sticky hands today thats for sure.  Everything he went near he cluncked clean as.

Has great forward smarts too.

22 minutes ago, Gawndy the Great said:

What was the whole May getting into his face? Felt  more than just a bit of banter.

I think Harmes went hard on May, gave a bit of niggle and Maysy wasn't having a bar of it.  Seriously how stupid would Harmes have to be going May.

Can someone please tell the MCG staff to TURN THE PA SYSTEM DOWN.

CAN'T HERE MYSELF THINK.

I know it's been this way for several seasons, but seriously it's ridiculous.  Doesn't improve the experience, it makes it worse.

2 hours ago, leave it to deever said:

How good to see the club having players leave on terms where they are happy to be back again.

I don't know why he left or was not renewed but having a player return is a big tick in my book.

Apparently reluctantly we made the call as part of the COVID playing list cut backs and Marty was overcoming an ACL.

https://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/1505993/hed-crawl-over-glass-hores-return-to-demons

Throw a bunch of spare salary cap money at him and see if we can land him. 

Would love to see him back (imagine him and JVR in the same forward line).

Equally I don't mind him being at the Giants and hope he continues to go well for them - just not against us!

So I think this is the sort of good news story this thread is about:

What champion bloke.

Said it in the other thread, that alot has been stated about our culture, but the media should have a good look at this bloke and see what character and culture is all about.

Watched him in our practice match against Richmond and thought he's clearly too good for VFL.

Best of luck to Marty on Sunday and hopefully there is a great second career in the making here at the Demons.

Worthy wearer of the No.27 too - love that he's got that number which has belonged to some great MFC defenders in my time as a supporter.

Goto say, I think Tomlinson was very stiff being dropped.  I haven't re-watched the replay of last week, but thought he was pretty solid and one of our better players last week.

Great work by Marty Hore, T Mac and BBB working their way back into the side.  Will see how they play, but I think all have worked hard in slightly different ways to get their way back into the senior team. 

If T Mac and BBB are sufficiently fit, then their more than capable of putting in good football performances.

Marty Hore - what a great effort in preservance to make it back from the VFL after being a mature age rookie to begin with.  Talk about MFC culture, I think this guy is made of the right stuff in this respects.

It's a pitty he isn't still in the Red and Blue really, I think we could be a bit thin for KP backs if May gets injured and our young guys in development don't come through.  Wounder how long he has left on his Freo contract and if we could actually lure him back?

14 minutes ago, ElDiablo14 said:

In our best years under Goodwin (2018 and 2021) I can't recall any such bad losses.

We were lucky not to loose in similar fashion in Rd 1, 2021 against Freo at the G.

Look what happened after that.

It's Rd 1.  Relax, it's a long season.

30 minutes ago, titan_uranus said:

Grundy was good but the key difference was he wasn't being blocked, checked, hit and kneed at every contest. Gawn was. We know this happens when we go in without proper ruck support. This has been happening for 8 years.

Watched this happen first hand against Brisbane at Cararra stadium back in 2020.  Charlie Cameron was blocking/shepherding and interrupting his free run at the contest practically every kick-in.  Yet not a single free kick was paid.  Just imagine if this type of behavior happened with Buddy.

How Gumby supporters like me can see this and the 1000 umpires on the ground can't is beyond me.  Particularly when there are umpires in the stands that see goals that are touched in slow motion (when they arn't) and call clear goals behinds with the same brilliant technology.

BTW,  I don't think it would be any use if we tried to support Max in this regard, as they'd see the free kick for any kind or defensive/retalitory action instantly.   Some players and team are protected species, yet ours clearly isn't in this category.

3 minutes ago, Sir Why You Little said:

Balls, we were thrashed all over the ground 

Umpires had no influence 

Please I'm begging - someone show me the vision that shows ANB's goal was actually touched.

Unless someone can, I'm calling them absolute cheats.  They have already got away with it once.

Just now, picket fence said:

Ur clutching at Straws!

Nup.  The match review upire was clutching at straws when he reversed that goal of ANB's.

Sydney wouldn't have even played finals last year if it wasn't for those fools.