SFebes

I'm critical of our older players and leaders, to his credit (Jones) he stood up well in the last 10mins after only having 4 kicks to half time from memory. What he did in the last 10 mins though is what should be expected of him each time we play the better teams, after all he is the captain. I thought he was quite poor before that but he needed to step up and did, so too Lewis. Jones' season has been sliding all year and hopefully he gets a chance to hold up the cup in appreciation of his loyalty. Still IMO an average player and poor leader but I'll be cheering him on in the next 6 weeks.

keep posting it then!

I told you pre-game they were bad. By far the worst supporters in the league IMO. They boo the siren, their own players, umpires....have never heard anything like it before.

How the MRO can judge force is beyond me. Do they judge by a replay? lol. Always has been a farce.

Not to forget Watts has been in the game longer and has 10 years more experience too.

Fair call mate, sorry about that.

TBH I don't believe any of them and if he was just going in to hear the proposed rule changes as a general fan, then why can't everyone else?

He's running at 63.8% DE for an outside runner, which isn't good enough IMO.

It's interesting. I'm no fan of Waleed however I think the joke is more on the AFL than him, which is the point. The AFL are desperate, they created this mess yet they are consulting every man and his dog on proposed rule changes. There has been a football fan forum and group set up which had a meeting in June I attended, the session did not go for long enough and proposed ideas from this were apparently laughed at by the AFL. The joke of it is the AFL and Gil himself, not Waleed Aly, who I don't think should have been approached anyway.

Don't know where to put it, so will just add here.

Gawn can rest in the bye before the finals, like all our other players.

Backpedaling, I wouldn't believe a word that comes out of his mouth nor the AFLs.

its a basketball on a seesaw.

Yeah probably is, I wasn't there as I said but a few posters had this opinion last week. Unfortunately I think Buggys papers are stamped, he's been in the best and most prolific at Casey for some time now. He provides something different, if only he could kick straight his record would be pretty good.

Whoops.

Oliver, Gawn, Hogan, Jetta, TMAC have all made it before haven't they?

Maybe Gil the Dil wants an opinion on how to make game look good from a TV perspective.....

I knew you'd love this!

https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/afl-2018-waleed-aly-sounded-out-by-afl-for-thoughts-on-state-of-the-game/news-story/420c2113a7904a370b8d70c972e1191b https://www.news.com.au/sport/afl/afls-consultation-of-waleed-over-state-of-game-slammed-by-warne/news-story/11be37c902141bc483372e9e99196d56

Apart from the OMAC non-HTB decision, if you mute the volume and watch without hearing the crowd booing to influence your theory, it was umpired quite fairly, they left it alone and let the 44 play. Plus the free kick count was 18-14 in WCE favour so wasn't totally rigged!

Apparently turned over many kicks so stats may be deceiving. I wasn't there though.

I get to most Cats games, family is surrounded with Cats supporters. Most supporters are outraged by his 4 year extension and many wanted him gone, or at least wait until the end of his contract to see next year. Has crumbled in finals, inherited his list from Bomber and tried to top up every year. Tried to buy a flag with Danger, who cant hit the side of a shed and has held on to many injury prone players and dead wood while they don't have a lot of top end junior talent. I think he's quite overrated as a coach, who was blessed with a core bunch from their glory days. Not to mention he's an arrogant pig. This season has been a failure for them "so far" with that midfield. He'd want to get them close this year and not hanging on to the 8 next year or their will be a riot at Kardinia Park, you hear it in the crowd during games. All supporters see is they have only won 3 of their last 11 finals, not good enough with that list.

No change.

Wore his heart on his sleeve and loved this club. He'd be handy in our backline this year too. Terrible luck for him but think the Pies will go deep next year.

Even I underrated him, we just have to get used to the fact that sometimes he'll only get 6 kicks and maybe snag 2-3 goals, he's not a high possession winner but loves crashing packs. Like an old fashioned full forward. You never know when he'll pop up.