leave it to deever

We probably shouldn't have had this poll.

Hes a likeable enough bloke but I"m afraid that if he goes gangbusters this year I will feel a tad shortchanged and feel like he didnt do enough for Melbourne. Catch 22 for me. Best to just move on and accept that he will be pretty much the same player except when he plays his old team and like the rest of them seem to do .... kick a huge bag. Just the way it is. I do hope we that don't treat him like Scully though.

He was good in the last game but was horrible in his 3 games b4 that. I hope he goes and plays well somewhere else .......best of luck to him. He had a great year last year but he fell away at the end of this one. Hes a seasoned player and needs to show leadership. He didnt and If we can get someone who can in his place we should.

Trengrove.......thanks for trying White Kennedy........couldnt cut it Spencer Bugg.........thanks for only playing half a season cos you have a bad temper, UNprofessional. Vince...done well Kent...doesnt seem interested. AND trade J watts.

Not sure if this is a fact. The first ball getter is tackled and may be pinged. Are there stats to support this?

It was interesting. As bad as we were 1st quarter the umps gave Pies 5 frees and 0 to us. In the the 3rd the frees were even ....11 each. IN the last they went back to giving pies 4 more. HUge impact at crucial times.

Dodgy as ever today

For the sake of matrimonial harmony I watch this show by myself.

No but the standard is woeful.

Not to take anything away on a most deserving player..... But where is everyone else apart from Hibberd and Neville? I suppose TMAC but thats about it.

Oliver.

We also haven't been smashed by other teams. In fact, there have been very few smashings this season so therein lies the answer. Teams have never been closer than this season. Yes, I would love to see us put Norf away by 12 goals but I'd be happy with a 1 point win as well. We need to put this year and last against the backdrop of a decade of shite. We are not beating teams by more than 40 points but we are at least beating teams we have not beaten for eons. From that angle this team is awesome.

Thanks for the tip but I'm afraid the only help for me would be some sort of Venn diagram posted above the telly. Speaking of which congrats on the little "on" . You will watch even more now but it will be shows like telly tubbies. Enjoy.

I get so confused with this bloody show.

Great thread. He deserves our admiration.

Most appropriate nickname "the wiz".........he was magical,,,,,,,,,,,,,an excitment machine. For the younger supporters think Garlett factor and double it.

You almost dont realise how bad the side was until you look at all the records. Sides must have waited with anticipation to play us and worse....... our team expecting to lose. So proud of the win against Hawks last year....Saints and crows this year. Lets follow up with a win this week and next. Last time 3 in a row?

I think their midfield review was before Oliver had asserted himself and before Lewis arrived. Remember how bad it was when Jones was tagged. Sometimes Vince picked up the slack. Watching the Dons game when Viney fired, WOW....how wrong did CD seem.

You must remember Rocktober

Are you sure it wasnt Wayne from St Albans?

Any chance of a line of Rodney Grinter balls? I.e basket, soccer, tennis etc.

You are one committed Melbourne supporter.

Playing so well for his age. Well done son. This team has oodles of talent.

For those who have compared Hogan to Stringer- Hogan is far better with his marking around the ground.

If we miss out on finals by 0.00132 of a percentage point....we will find him.