45HG

He is happy to give players 2 year contracts as he understands we cannot give unproven individuals too-long of a stint, I can't see why he would be so against this contract. Obviously, I reject that analogy. Would you settle for Megan Fox?

Cricket for me died a little bit on January 5th, 2007 with the last ball of England's innings. Despite a dominate display at the World Cup later that same year, cricket has never been the same for me.

Jurrah's ability below the knees does not count out his ability in the air, it is simply an added strength. I have used the Farmer comparison in the past, but to say he's better along the ground than Farmer was at 21 is ludicrous in my view.

Fair call, I just don't see a lot of flexibility in there - marking types and a few of them suspect below the knees. Your Roughead/Franklin, Brown/Bradshaw only highlights what I'm saying - positions in the modern game are fluid. There is no true FF - otherwise you wouldn't use the Roughead/Franklin comparison because one would be a FF.

There is no "true FF" anymore IMO anyway - so I think that concern can be dispelled. Your forward line containts 5 "talls," not to mention one guy with questionable character.

Solomon, M Johnson, Bradley, Mcphee. A fair recruitment policy it would seem.

Jurrah strikes me as the sort of man who WANTS to be our main goal kicker. I don't give two f's about people on his band wagon - he is a KPP who should learn his craft now. Especially considering that he will be 21 next year.

I see Bailey as a very level headed person who would continue on his path. He has so far. Why would he stop with a two year contract? It's not like he has reputation to fall back on. He is a determined, professional man. I like the direction he's heading in. And I have not ever heard him say he wants a three year contract, when has he said that?

But who is Darren Bradshaw? By God man, why would you want a player over 30? What would it achieve in terms of winning a premiership?

What about a two year contract we have been offering to anyone who's not Davey?

I hope that people realize that selecting his brother in a fairytale design will leave is with about 1/3 of a team of Grimes' in future years

Would we be interested in Daniel Bradhshaw though?

I don't think I've seen a first year MFC player with KPF so emblazened on him as I've seen from Jurrah - yet posters maintain a desire to see him play the sneaky fill, off to the side role.

Or if Jordy did his usual kicking action.

Looks like Riewoldt...plays like Koschitzke. Sorry, I know they are different types of players, but I just don't rate Kosi. You get the drift.

Not good enough for 34 or too good (likely gone) by 50?

Would probably agree with that

Man youse wud not be az gud az daw...doood i sawd hutchie ( ) show da hilites on my tv and he looks fuli sik!!!111!! For the record everyone is on the panel

If anything that only builds the view that there really are no set positions in the game anymore as they have all become fluent. I see what you're saying, and it may well be right, but in general I believe he will attract at least their second best defender - assuming match ups work.

45 points in a half!

I'm looking at Daw for pick 11 but if he's gone by then you're in HT

Would you have said last year that Trav was a good player?

The demonland match review panel would like to warn posters of harsh beer penalties for those who engage with TOX. Don't forget: Never argue with idiots - they'll drag you down to their level and beat you with experience.

Will he claim to travel for a year if picked up by another club?

Reckon you could shoot a PM my way DD? Name a game has always been ridiculously priced in my eyes - $30+ for a single match is outrageous in my mind.