John Demonic

C camp ?

It's lower risk to chip it around holding a lead taking time off the clock, than to kick a goal and run the higher risk of the 6/6/6 reset giving the other team momentum and repeated 6/6/6 bounces. That is why I think low scores and possession footy. Its a mockery. Just wait until a team gives away a zone free kick deliberately against momentum, to avoid a deep inside 50 entry from great tap work and streaming forward clearances. Because a ruckman taking a free kick from the centre and bombing it into 50 even with 6/6/6 zones is a preferable entry/result.

Donald Duck has been captaining Geelong for years

You actually should have to question team selections based on players form. If he was carrying an injury, well then that explains a lot. However the "Beyond question" aspect of team selection needs to be dialled back a touch. Players get old and their abilities start waning. You can expect this to occur for Jetta soon enough. He isn't having as big an impact as he was in 2017 and started last year poorly too. To his credit he had a big 2nd half last year. Questioning is fine, people in here do it to Lewis ad nauseum. Questioning, especially if players like Hore, Wagner & Petty make a bigger impact in the seniors as time goes on should be fine. I'm not writing him off, but if he has a poor patch of form in the next month, other players deserve a go too.

While I think Lewis deserves to be straight in due to his experience in aiding structure on the G, I too question whether Jetta should come straight back in given he was out of form in the first 3 games and I read somewhere he was losing 50% contests. There should be no favourites. Good call. Edit: Having said that we might need him to play on Gresham as he's a gun and Jets might thrive on locking down a quality small fwd.

No, but i'm guessing he talked about taking it one week at a time a lot?

Sam Reid

Good luck Big Fella!

You really try and shoehorn your anti-Lewis rhetoric into almost every topic and have particularly doubled down this week in the face of hard evidence (0-7) to the contrary. It reeks of desperation.

Zak Jones had a BOG game last week with 31pos and 7 clearances, Maybe throwing his brother on him for a hard tag could liven things up with a bit of bite and reinvigorate him for this weeks game at least.

I've already booked a corporate box on the wing for round 23 Spoonbowl v Nth Melbourne.

600k plus performances clauses that unlock the extra 100k each year. You can't lock in a key forward with future prospects for any less these days surely? If he wants to go somewhere else with that on the table, then you'd have to question his buy-in

Good. Throw in a new kid with zippy pace, can't be any worse than having ANB up forward.

Maybe we can rip it up some more and play a game of NRL on thursday night at the ScrumCG

Hawthorn are still one of the oldest teams in the comp, they would have budgeted far more money than us from their future retirements including Roughhead. And that's not even to mention that he'd probably take unders to go there compared to us. No chance, look elsewhere.

Give up the chase, Hawthorn are already linked to him. https://www.afl.com.au/news/2019-04-06/cashedup-hawks-linked-to-recovering-giants-forward-patton

Fair call. The last week has been a tumultuous time as a demon fan and it's awful and emotional seeing issues from last year unaddressed and leading to our demise so far this year, so it's hard to look back right now and ignore those faults and see the progress we did make. The overall block of progress from 2014 onwards has been a brilliant boon for the club however, so we've been on the right track and it's been a bumpy but worthwhile ride. But now it just feels like we may be at a fork in the road where a lot of the good work may become undone with a poor season that leaves us as run-of-the-mill as many other teams with a list full of potential that may never fulfill itself, while other lists do. And now to top it off our prize recruit that was our great promise of holding together our backline came back unfit and overweight, an absolute disgrace! 3 weeks in though, need to calm down.

Maybe he's been smashing burgers all off season with Relton Roberts?

Ironically, the seasons 2nd half might be a more entertaining block of games if we finally click, than last year. When we have our backs against the wall and are in do-die games to make the 8, things could get interesting. With winnable games and then: WCE, Rich, Coll, Syd. We're so far from it, but if we can beat those clubs, it would provide us with some momentum going into 2020, even if we miss the finals. Just like it did for the Bulldogs last year. All is not lost if we get our gameplan in order and show up and prove we can match those clubs. If our [censored] falls out from under us and we don't put in any effort because the finals hope is over, well then god help us for next year.

It sounds like Goodwin just expects everything to click and go our way eventually and we just streamroll teams with one way chaos-ball momentum. It's all a bit one dimensional.

The rose colored glass mob in this forum have been blindsided by this, refusing to see that last years unaddressed deficiencies would be our downfall this year. (Although we all have to this 0-3 extent) The elephant in the room is that we should've missed the finals last year but had some fortunate circumstances go our way with Kennedy missing and GWS already cemented in the 8. We were continually destroyed by fast teams that used the wide expanses of the G all year. ALL YEAR I asked "when are we going to get a big win like in 2017?" Our big wins turned out to be False Dawns. A terrible Adelaide by 100, and WCE over there without their key pillars. The same problems last year with our defence and lacklustre forward entries, have now turned into the key reasons for our demise as other teams have worked us out. All of that papered over because wE MaDe ThE PreLiM. We beat up on the weak teams but continually failed against the better teams. Sadly the weak teams have now improved ten fold and we've been exposed.

? All you can do is laugh/cry.

Have we signed Luke Hodge to replace him?

The way I see this playing out is that We will beat the Bombers irrespective of the changes we make at the table. We're just better than them if our core players are on. The real problem is the false equivalence that a win justifies the teams selection, because we're just going to end up exposed week/s later against a better team when the FD are choosing the same players and leaving the same issues unaddressed.

We had Omac + Frost and Fritsch/Gawn as intercept last year. Why are we going Omac + Frost and May as intercept? Lever will come in and May will be lock down. 1 of Frost/Omac is superfluous to our needs long term, but we should still be going with Fritsch or Gawn dropping back. Having J Wagner as 3rd tall isn't really enough.