Ugottobekidding

Windsor is a 2nd year player who missed a huge chunk of preseason. Most players struggle when missing most of the preseason.

Do a y of our decisions make sense

Thank you for your reply. Yes and Simon Simon won in 2021. It is now 2025.

Hasn't been able to get the swans over the line.

Good old Cam Bruce or Hanson from Carlton

More he flip flops if it doesn't work straight away. You need to stick to a plan. Not just rotate players in and out continually.

I reckon Clarry has to go for his sake and ours. Probably best for both parties.

Buckley left Collingwood and they are suddenly a better team. No more dinosaurs, got try a younger and more innovative coach. I would say Goodwin no longer can manage the players, I would say he has lost the group. Words are one thing but actions on the field talk louder. He got a premiership but he won't get us another.

Goodwin needs to go along with a good cleanout

Generally how Goodwin destroys most young players

Casey situation needs an overhaul. Incapable of developing any players with this setup.

Finals for Melbourne

Tholstrop is coming of a interrupted preseason. Give him sometime to get things working.

Not dead but season is over, not getting any better. Three wins against easy sides.

And it really comes down to Goodwin who has been out of his depth on the forward line issue. The club needs to hire a forward coach. But from what I have heard, it's Goodwins way or no way. Which is why it is hard to get assistant coaches to join.

Good the list is where Goody has steered it. The club should have axed the love machine last year.

Ash Hanson never gets a mention but is considered a highly tactical and rigorous eye. Get the feeling he is waiting for Boss to get the chop.

There is no way he can continue now. Club has to stop the rot and that means taking hard decisive action. We have been going backwards each year since our premiersjip

Rather swap AJ for Campbell and tell him to make a contest in the ruck when needed

A new coach would be a better start

Move Rivers back into the engine room. Would play Lindsay as half forward flank. Move Fritch back to the pocket. Play Van Toyon centre half forward. Play disco full forward and keep Langford in the guts. Fritch needs to play close to goal. Defence is a bit of a disaster

Was Goodwin there or hiding?

They should be sounding out a new coach ready to step in.

Goodwin has only himself to blame - the list management and coaching has been ordinary.

Lindsay, Langford and Windsor are the future. Probably give Rivers the chance to captain the side. Trade for a forward and Backman and get some decent mids.