WERRIDEE

I never said he was no good he was excellent until we won the Premiership. He's been hit and miss since then. Langford is a hit, but it looks like Jefferson is a miss, Kolt could be a miss, too early to tell about Lindsay and Windsor didn't come on this year.

Throw in Ainsworth for nothing and you have a deal.

He was used as a pure midfielder in the reserves.

Oliver was a champion until 2022. He has ruined his legacy with his issues the last 2 years and why we won't get anything back for him which is a shame.

He know a bit more than you it's his job. You haven't told me why North and Richmond don't want to go through the draft? As what's been said the draft is a gamble. This draft is even more of a gamble. Taylor isn't as good as you think he is. He was great til we won the premiership he's been hit and miss since then.

Why people think recruiting just kids is baffling you need a mixture of both. Twomey has already said that after Duursma and Duff-Tyler not including Uwland who is an academy pick the draft drops off dramatically. North opted to give this years pick away to get 2 last year. Richmond want to trade this years 3 and 4. I hope your not baffled now.

I know I bang on about how poor the draft is but aren't you all glad that it's a poor draft. Essendon will get another Tstas and Hobbs while we got Langford and Lindsay. Essendon the gift that keeps on giving.

We won't get 12 for Clarry we might have last year but Goodwin stupidly kept him. 32 at best.

No the first 3 are great. It drops dramatically after that. You may get an ok player after that but they will be no Petracca.

A Neeld culture of spoons is what it will give. I've already said in another he's a professional he will give his all at whatever club he plays for. He hasn't held them to ransom like he did last year. He'd be happy to stay if a deal doesn't get done.

That's just untrue. They said the same thing last year and he finished second in the B&F ahead of Kossie who was All Australian and finished with 16 votes in the Brownlow. Not bad for someone who was half hearted. He's a professional he will give his all no matter what club he plays at.

Were you the same person that said pick 7 for Curnow? Pick 7 doesn't even come close it's insulting really.

Not when it comes to Trac he can come around. When it comes to culture killers like May and Oliver then sure get rid of them.

Getting 2 ordinary picks for Petracca will put us on the bottom. I don't know why people want picks knowing this is an ordinary draft. Petracca is our second best player. Pay up or he stays should be the motto. Every suggestion you have made puts us on the bottom. Your any deal will do for Petracca is just plain stupid. Graham poor mans Peatling you have no idea.

You've lost the plot. You want us to be on the bottom forever. Sounds like 2012.

because they are getting Petracca and Academy kids, they can afford to lose Humphrey. Who are you? Tim Lamb? You are soft honesty gets you nowhere. We won't be getting King or Butters if we are on the bottom. I don't care if they see Humphrey in their premiership team. We want him if you want Petracca you give him to us. That's what I'd be saying. Pick 7, Humphrey and Ainsworth for Trac deal done CLOSE THREAD.

If we are giving away Trac for nothing then we will be near the bottom and Butters and King ain't going to a bottom club.

We don't need picks in a terrible draft. We need players.

We are reluctant to let Petracca go he's still got 4 years on his contract. If Humphrey isn't part of the trade it doesn't get done. You think he can't stay I beg to differ. Hell no. Curnow is a star I'd be wanting one of their best players for him or he stays just like Trac.

Fox are kidding themselves? Pick 7 and a pick upgrade in a shocking draft. That is certainly devaluing a Norm Smith Medalist. If that deal is done Lamb gets the sack.

Rubbish. Humphrey ATM is nowhere near as good as Trac. Humphrey and pick 7 is a minium. Graham you got to be joking? You are undervaluing Trac.

We are not giving him away for nothing like you want to do.

We will take more than 1 pick but don't expect anything from them. The top 20 in last years draft would be top 3 in this years draft.

That's a terrible deal. Davies is a spud. Keep Petracca if that's the best deal we can come up with.

If we get Humphrey and pick 7 maybe Ainsworth thrown in I could handle that, but it now has to be Humphrey or no dice. I don't understand Flanders he'd walk into our midfield without Clarry and Trac, possibly be the main man. Why wouldn't he want that?