WERRIDEE

Sloane is too old for our list. Gaff is what we need, Mackay is what we don't need. I don't think we need a back up ruckman, Weideman will do a good enough job until youngsters like King, Filipovic and Bradtke step up. Dahlhaus hasn't had a kick for 2 years damaged goods.

That's the exact reason we don't know how good he could he could be. He was a relatively high draft pick. Putting him on a rookie list won't hurt and if he's still injured all of next year delist him.

Don't play Frost it will be a step backwards like playing Pedersen last game. Play Petty for height or Baker for speed. How many chances does Frost need to prove that he is unworthy?

Good job? T.Mac is top 5 and Fritsch, Spargo and O.Mac could be higher and Hunt could be lower.

If he continues his recent form he's every chance to stay but if his form drops he's a goner

When has a defender been used as a second ruck? He'll be a forward if he replaces Pedersen.

Very harsh on Viney he has an average game and your after him you didn't say that when he got 35 touches against Adelaide. He is a gun. The whole midfield was down against the Pies watch them bounce back against Port.

Vince, Lewis and Jones are more than enough and Pedersen won't be around next year. We can't be crazy enough to add a injury prone veteran to that list.

That should be our only priority. The people who want Murphy are out of their minds, we are not a retirement village.

For me it's delist Pedersen, Bugg, JKH, Johnstone, McKenna, Keilty Trade Tyson, Stretch, Josh.Wagner, Garlett, Kent and Frost Promote Tim.Smith Rookie McKenna

I say no to Carlton hacks no matter what price but yes please to Gaff he is a gun.

I don't want to hang him or applaud him before he done something all I know is he has big shoes to fill. Jackson has been great for this club, don't let us down Perty..

Replying and liking yourself Dazzle you've hit a new low even for you.

Doubled his clearences even back then. Trengove could never get his own ball that's his problem and his obvious lack of pace. We should have Martin that should even be obvious to clowns like wiseblood.

When are you gonna admit that you are the same clown as Dazzle. Thank god you won't read my posts again because I don't rate you either. Whiny [censored]. He was never destined to be a star just another spud from the Prendergast factory.

He was a poor choice he could never get a clearance and was terribly slow and injury prone. Another disgraceful choice by Prendergast. We should have Dusty. Trengove is overrated because he is injury prone. Couldn't get a for us and can't get a game for Port he is a hopeless footballer. I stand by that it was a disgraceful decision to pick him up it was as bad as Toumpas.

Let's face it he's no Bayley Fritsch.

We will win the premiership, one bad loss won't make our season. We will bounce back against Port and go undefeated for the rest of the season. Bring in Baker and Petty and watch us fly. TAKE THAT DEEFELLA GO THE MIGHTY DEES!

A bit hard when your emergency, he's close to a recall if that is anything to go by. Just hope Stretch doesn't get a go, VFL standard player like Pedo, Frost, Bugg and JKH they should give up on all of them they have had their chances.

Tyson will definitely play. Our team was a disgrace changes have to be made. Doubt Spargo will get another go form has been poor. Pedo better not get another game he was a disgrace.

That's a joke right?

God your a clown Biff

I rate our performance 7\10 due to playing no one and the Pies dinting our flag hopes. Tom.McDonald has impressed me the most coming off his serious injury. Fritsch is the draftee that has had the biggest impact. Adelaide has been our best win. Petracca needs to improve in the second half of the season. Collingwood has been our most disappointing performance. Call me crazy but I still think we can finish top 2 but we have to play a hell of a lot better than we did against the Pies. Win\loss record 18\4

I think 3 certain changes. Weideman for Pedo Garlett for Spargo Tyson for who ever Petty and Baker I think will give us a better structure. Petracca gets another chance due to Hunt's injury.

I still think we can win the flag but changes have to be made. Our lack of pace has to be one of them. I'm sure our midfield won't have a shocker again like they did against the pies.