DubDee

Bring back Misson!

I have zero concern. We are no longer a club that loses quality players. And if we did lose Clarry it would be due to professional incompetence on and off the field and we would deserve the result. Every club would want him but if he left it would be for success, which would leave the Blues well and truely out of the running I refuse to be drawn into this discussion (until maybe June when I start to panic)

I reckon and hope you are assuming too much. He is not a proven fwd and if he is our starting 22 up fwd we are in big trouble imo I think he is just recruited for cover in case T Mac and M Brown etc also go down

No doubt we need Fritsch and LJ up front. I reckon T Mac deserves a few games to see if he has returned to his old form. If he fails, bring in M Brown But after that I would like some flexibility. Trac maybe 50-50, we don't want to lose his explosiveness at stoppages too much Add in Hunt, Laurie (?) and Kozzi and there is plenty of pace and skill and pressure

Agreed

He played fwd a few times but showed he doesn’t have the craft to be a key fwd so they moved him back. Aside from that one game he has proved to be a poor fwd so hopefully we don’t have to go through this experiment for him to fail again. he reminds me a bit of Frost up fwd, lots of physical traits and a good mark but not much else. He is decent down back however.

I mean holding down a spot, playing multiple games in a row. Over 11 seasons he only had one decent patch and he was down back, where we are pretty well covered. So perhaps more accurate wording would be he has shown he is not a consistent AFL player. And that is a poor team that was crying out for decent players. Even Jimmy Toumpas looked a star in his highlights

no worries, I'll quit my job and start working as a talent scout on no money Us thinking of the first 6 weeks of the season could be short sighted. We have guys like M Brown that are ready to go, to fill in if needed. a younger longer term prospect would be more worthwhile imo. i find it hard to believe there would be no prospects anywhere

Pity we missed out on Mason Wood, we could have inherited the entire dominant Roos fwd line finals here we come!

Cartlidge on the knee. could be worse. hopefully will be back late April and play the season out.

yeah, I'm aware that's what has happened. I am just voicing my opinion that I think it's a bad call. or should we not never question potential recruiting decisions on this forum?

remember that time he kicked 6 goals?? lol one game in 10 seasons

no idea, I'm not a talent scout and I dont watch the lower leagues much. but it seems logical there would be some decent ruck talent in the country that is not on an AFL list

He had an arthroscope and should be 6 weeks but who the [censored] knows

You don’t have to argue back. I’m just putting my opinion out there

You could be right. Maybe this is what they are thinking. I’d have Tomo as a lock on the backline with May and lever with petty and smith as back up. And you live with just two with hibbo and rivers

Thanks for the reply. I guess in essence I’d prefer to not take a bloke who has proven over 11 seasons not capable of playing AFL standard footy. I’d take a punt if someone else. thanks also for explaining how a ‘list works’. Most enlightening

He is depth down back which we don’t need. Average ruck, poor fwd.

Mostly off his athleticism and potential I’d guess. 10 years on AFL list of a mostly struggling club. Averaged 5 games a season

Mature talls like McDonald, M Brown and even Tomnilson? Out talls are pretty balancing. Just need them to fire. Daw adds almost nothing aside from the dreaded ‘depth’

I think it’s mostly because he is not very good at playing football

Poor fwd, average ruck and decent Backman. doesnt make a lot of sense to me. We have some average fwd back up options, we don’t need more If we were after a ruck back up I’d have preferred we picked a youngish ruckman from the vfl or other lower levels that might develop

I reckon Jimmy would have been proud to see three Dubs on our list and Goldrick playing so well. Can we not get some for the mens team?!

BOG - Hanks/ Mithin/ goldrick fantastic win. Best AFLW game I’ve seen. Girls hard as nails. We’ve had the talent but I saw the grit tonight.

After all of your previous comments on AFLW I never thought you would either! Go Demons!