Demonsone

Lots of mental issues with this group..... Leak too many goals & would get smashed against top teams.... These are the questions which Goodwin needs to answer.... Another missed opportunity & as much as the past dosent matter for Goody it continues to raise its ugly head!

Picks 1, 2 & 4 playing in the port magoos!

The talk on a trade Petracca or Oliver for Lever is ridiculous & dumb! These young guns are part of our future & would be pointless after securing them from early picks.

Just funny how things could work out...We got Tyson, Salem & Hunt from this deal so was a win on both teams

Imagine that... We gave up our pick 2 to GWS in 2013 who picked Josh Kelly & we will need to pay overs to get him now...

Some of the comments here honestly .. Lewis contribution thus far has been great .. barring his striking charge his experience & hardness & teaching the young group & even older players what culture is required to win 4 flags! His possessions continue to be in our top group of players ... honestly don't know what some supporters expect he is only 1 of 22 & plenty of others who hardly touched the ball!

Footy gods against us re injuries.... Dumbness by Lewis & Hogan... Tigers getting exited who struggled to beat a side on one leg!

Honestly if he leaves for home factors may as well desolve the draft as its a joke.. Completely makes a mockery of it as it was designed for clubs to recruit & build a list.. Not develope players so clubs like freo, swans etc can walk in & get a ready made gun! Keep on saying at least the Epl et can sell players which allows them to go & buy a bunch of players ..

Expectations too high for kpp in his second year of footy!

End of this season not that bad as stated in other posts mgr wants to maximise his value... But afl just can't sit back & have a so called equalisation comp with early picks only to see them leave to a stronger club after hes been developed! People bag the English premier league but smaller clubs can develop players & sell them which allows them to buy other players to strengthen their squads etc early draft picks don't compensate & are always risky as they may fail..

People get real.. Need to be successful to attract an A grader.. gotta get better & developing A graders!

Exactly... 09 we had 1,2,11,18.... Trengove only one left, but injured for 2 yrs... We got compensated for Scully but when you throw in all the rest of our early picks over a 10 yr period it's no wonder we continue to rebuild.... Compare us to Hawks who had 2 super drafts of 01 & 04 which is basically the nucleus of their premiership teams...

Not all trades work... But can anyone on here state their credentials & exp on player talent... Let's trust the club....

Roos is all class.... We need to respect that most of the players his team has brought in have worked well.. Vince is evident that our culture & environment has come fwd a fair bit.. He was all but gone @ the crows & to win a b&f says it all...

Great to focus on the positives like Hogan instead of the damn 40sec which the media have done to death! One can only imagine players like Brayshaw, Viney, petracca, Salem,Tyson, toumpas kicking the ball to Hogan!

Why not

Club needs to create a culture of long term players.. Though the current free agency has changed the rules.. I think if you commit to long term with kpp you develop a strong spine which you can build a great club ....

Offer him a 7yr contract

All these records wil be broken when we build a club both off & on the field which can challenge playing finals & grand finals...this will not happen overnight ... Look at the clubs like haw, Geel & swans it took them a decade to build those lists

Give it up.... Support the players we have not the 1s we should have could have blah blah About time this club actually created an environment were players are developed to high afl standards... I'm sure if you looked @ clubs like haw, Geel, swans the difference would be night & day!