Demonsone

We will never know what the review unearthed, I have been calling out our inability to trade in quality exp fwds etc and unsure why they have never been linked to any names except for Houston, do they have cap space issues? Was playing Oliver in the seniors after missing preseason split the group? Question is why has it taken so long to appoint a CEO as he quit end of Oct???

It’s curtains for him! I’m sorry you don’t improve your list with VFL mature age players & no disrespect to them , consider who the pies, cats, lions, swans & hawks have traded in, his game plan is shot with zero defensive & contest, played with a fwd line of Jvr the only tall, this is comical!

Needed to be gone after the second straight sets exit! Why his contract was extended twice in 22/23 is beyond belief! He’s failed to adapt & implement a new game plan unwound all the defensive & contest , flip flop it lad year & coaches from the box then runs down to the boundary .. it’s shows he dosent have trust & second guessing… its more than him it’s the whole club no leadership, no ceo , president in waiting, back to amateurism

Goodwin needed to go after he’s second straight sets exit with all the so called culture issues, playing Oliver after missing preseason I’m sorry sends a poor message to the others busting their read ends, issues riddled from the president down to CEO , Green I feel for him and no CEO how do I make longer term decisions

Have been in denial since the straight sets in 22, our trading in of older rejects has done nothing to improve our list, is list mgt or blind faith or have those long expensive contracts sucked up the cap we agreed to trac, Oliver , Viney , Brayshaw?? Has this fractured the group?? The whole club is in denial with no leadership

Listened to Goodwin presser … stated the same BS but to hear the players lacked fight wow .. how many premiership exp players do we have that can’t find fight ????

Great review! The writing has been on the wall, culture issues, a coach whose game has been flawed & failed to adapt! Our poor list management on not improving the list! Trying to turn defenders into fwds, the Grundy disaster, Who’s responsible for the unraveling of this list & the club back in the toilet with no CEO & fill in President!

Followed this club since 72 & member since 98, always find a way to fall of the cliff 0-5 , burn any decent players , implode off the field, and still no home base whilst the hawks have manage to build their second since 2000… a club going around in circles

Spot on, those big contracts can split the group & the restaurant debacle, cap issues no doubt impacting on trading in big names & losing players Jordan, Bedford etc we are a mess again interim president & CEO it’s a disgrace

A review was done, yet with Pert who’s no longer there! A club without a permanent President, CEO .. nothing against Green… but it’s time for Goody & a list mgt shake up … to have basically no talls in the Fwd line us a joke after 3 years of winning a flag , Goodwin has completely unwound the foundations of contest & defence set by Roos ..I’d be surprised if trac dosent request a trade.

Trac w Only one person responsible for this debarcle

He has coached out every ounce of contest & defence, it’s amateurish what he’s done! I don’t blame Trac if he says I want out we are deplorable ..Green do the right thing as president or club is about to enter 2012 Neeld era

What a joke , reinforces Goodwin confusion coaching from the box & then comes down .. that reinforces he has no answers

Has completely removed any of our contest & defence we had , the continued bombing to a short fwd line, not picking Turner a tall wtf he has to go he’s lost the plot

This is Neeld era bs

Goodwin has destroyed this team , for 3 seasons the continued long bombs & zero fwds who can take a mark it’s deplorable

The Dogs are similar club to us , only 1 flag in 60yrs & didn’t maximise their premiership clock, yet they have found ways to somehow reinvent themselves & haven’t bottomed out …Let’s see if/how Goodwin can pull us out of deep hole

Great to see Nth playing well! If this isn’t alarm bells 🔔 on Goodwin tenure

The consistency of our club trading players from other clubs who couldn’t get a game & sitting @ Casey is such a poor reflection of were we are at! Either our list manager has no idea or we don’t have cap space, or any decent player refuses to come due to culture issues! I see forwards like Darling & Membry whilst at the end of their careers I shake my head as we clearly have a fwd issue!

Our list hasn’t improved sure our drafting of young players great but our trading of experienced talent is very poor ..you only need to look at who the pies, cats, lions, & hawks have brought in.

Membery , Mcstay , Schultz, Houston , perryman vs vfl vfl vfl vfl

Culture & trading vfl quality! Just compare the trades

Wow imagine trading in forwards who can take a mark & goal!

Watching the Swans & pies ball movement forwards kicking goals vs us go around in circles & missing shots

Agree .. let’s not forget the state gvt have giving 140 mill to redevelop their stadium over the last 15yrs whilst we are stuck training on a paddock & driving 50 mins to Casey & a pipe dream horse racing track as a training centre