CityDee

Lively tough decent by hand and foot . Spargo and Viney will be pressure beasts working in tandem around the footy .

Nice to see some dash and speed and looks the type to win his own ball .

Was hoping crows or power would take a punt on Trenners , will be watching to see how Watts and Trenners go next year. No doubt Wattsy will kill it - Go Trenners . !

Honestly what I have seen of this guy was a good hard running attack on the footy . Small sample size though.

Havnt seen alot but the things that stand out are his attack toughness and his speed . Could be worth a look

Pick 31

He was a great player but injured up until he played 7 games this year . Im happy you support the club Pro dee good to see . a good trade out by the tiges - we have been screwed on pick 31 for watts for sure his future output will be more than pick 31 is worth . hope it was special for you .

Lids didnt play many games for two seasons? It made sense to let another medical team try and get his calf right . Prodee are you a melbournefc member?

Thats right they have given a neeld esque wack and its put most offside and that will include the playing group im sure.

Yeah he said that he wasnt the person his wife married!! And the group would have sharing sessions each player had to share somthing with the group ( initiated by a consultant apparently) Rewoildt said the previous year they couldnt wait to get out of the place due to the vibe this year was obviously different . I worry that we are making a mistake with the Watts trade in regards to the group . Time will tell .

This thing about club culture and the tough stance mark neeld anyone? It doesnt work with the younger generation , look what won the tiges the flag this year? Hardwick brought the group together , the watts sacking could have a lasting confusing effect on the playing group.

I reckon your right - despite the vocal 30% against watts most watchers cant really fault the guy without falling into discussion that doesnt add up . Go back and watch the doggies win the guy is more than serviceable, cracks in and plays smart footy reading the ball trying to gain advantages ( a snap shot yes ) There is somthing missing and I believe now that the lever deal and a contract or two is the missing narrative that Mahoney and gang have left out . They had to choose someone and again it was the whipping boy . Pick 31 what a joke . And paying part of his salary . we have given up two first rounders and jack Watts for lever and pick 31 .

Terrible trade Sorry to see ya go Jack . Goodluck .

‘The Pill little center of excellency ‘

It has to be a pick 20-25 think about it clubs getting compensation picks in the late first round for guys like frawley and motlop , Watts is worth more no doubt . Lets swap Watts for Ollie wines and give them a player or pick and get a pick back .

So we lose Hogan and Watts in these scenarios suggested- coach killer .

We are losing our best kick in Watts I wouldnt be sending Wagner off anywhere he can use it and on this thread I think the FD has done a great job resurrecting our list with Josh at the helm and wouldnt be surprised if they futher our picks position as you have suggested. I totally disagree with the watts trade though - see the watts thread for that one .

Say it aint so Jack . This thread should be renamed- ‘the ultimate whipping boy’ a sad lesson in getting ahead of ourselves, a masterpiece.

He comes across as an honest well rounded guy who along with the footy department have built a good list . kelly hasn’t been injured who knows he may have had salems bad luck if he was at the dees . Crystal balling , we got two for the price of one really Dom can play. cant get a superstar with every pick . Hibberd lever melksham are good pickups sometimes you gotta give a little up to get these types . Im happy we are a realistic club. Good on you for having a different view than most !

I reckon so its a good draft - hoping we land a first rounder somehow .

If Plapp and Vineys have the info pre docker and issues why not . Id trust em with my son although it would be a little intimidating bunking in the viney house!! Father and son having a playfight after watching lone wolf mcquade .

I do agree we need to add outside run and finish but more of the caliber of player We would need to swap for - maybe a lachie witfield type with some pics exchanging, I know im dreaming but so far the club seems to be demanding somthing good .

No way on Menzel .

Unless we get a young future champ like a zac jones type forget it( if Jack succumbed to being pushed out ) shuffle of picks may be required but there is the value in my opinion.

Jack -‘ Ah listen Simon - I just want someone that will back me in ‘ Simon - ‘Jack , look , Ive been sitting back here watching you do things in patches that only a handful of players in the comp can do , Im not sure I can coach you to do that consistently ‘ Jack - ‘ I know Ive let the club down in a few areas but Im here to work hard be treated like any other player and i reckon its time we put the gloves on ‘ Simon - ‘what ? ‘ Jack - ‘ Let me show ya Simon , Ive been over to Vines house the last month and learnt a few tricks ‘ Simon - ‘Ok jack ‘ Weird dream last nite .