I know this has been done to death but new rumours of Chris Judd leaving WCE has surfaced. with trade period only 3 weeks away, it is highly topical again. it seems Judd is not that happy at WCE (and with their gangster, druggy culture who could blame him tbo) and would not rule out coming back to melbourne to play footy.

Now let's make a huuugggeee assumption. trade week has just started and Judd nominated the demons as his prefered club to play for (ala Akermanis and bulldogs). it is now up to WestCoast and demons to make a deal that is reasonable and fair to both sides...

Who would you be willing to trade for Judd?

NOTE: Judd is in the top 3 players in the afl. we have not had a player in the top 20 players in the afl for about 10 years!!! he is a genuine superstar and you have to give up quality to get quality!!!

My possible trade:

1) Johnstone and pick 4 to WCE (quality midfield replacement and top draft pick)

Judd and pick 40something to MFC

2) Pick 4, Sylvia and Davey to WCE (high pick, and 2 young quality upncomers)

Judd and pick 40ish to MFC

3) pick 4, pick 21 and Mclean to WCE (2 good draft picks and Mclean a gun youngster)

Judd and Staker to Melbourne to MFC

I know I am a one eyed demon supporter, but are these fair trades?i reckon all of mine of probably well in favour of us, but keep in mind that if Judd nominates us then WestCoast are a little bit stuck in that they have to bargain with us or risk losing him in the PSD...

oh how id love to see Judd at melbourne. finally we would have a player whos actually in the top 2 players in the league.

What would people give up for him?

3) pick 4, pick 21 and Mclean to WCE (2 good draft picks and Mclean a gun youngster)

I stopped reading there. You're all blinded my Brocks (and our) shithouse season. Brock McLean is still oozing with leadership qualities and under no circumstances should be traded. That's right, not even for god...

look i know this has been done to death...

but new rumours of Chris Judd leaving WCE has surfaced. with trade period only 3 weeks away, it is highly topical again. it seems Judd is not that happy at WCE (and with their gangster, druggy culture who could blame him tbo) and would not rule out coming back to melbourne to play footy.

now let's make a huuugggeee assumption. trade week has just started and Judd nominated the demons as his prefered club to play for (ala Akermanis and bulldogs). it is now up to WestCoast and demons to make a deal that is reasonable and fair to both sides...

who would you be willing to trade for Judd.

NOTE: Judd is in the top 3 players in the afl. we have not had a player in the top 20 players in the afl for about 10 years!!! he is a genuine superstar and you have to give up quality to get quality!!!

My possible trade:

1)

Johnstone and pick 4 to WCE (quality midfield replacement and top draft pick)

Judd and pick 40something to MFC

2)

Pick 4, Sylvia and Davey to WCE (high pick, and 2 young quality upncomers)

Judd and pick 40ish to MFC

3)

pick 4, pick 21 and Mclean to WCE (2 good draft picks and Mclean a gun youngster)

Judd and Staker to Melbourne to MFC

i know i am a one eyed demon supporter, but are these fair trades?i reckon all of mine of probably well in favour of us, but keep in mind that if Judd nominates us then WestCoast are a little bit stuck in that they have to bargain with us or risk losing him in the PSD...

oh how id love to see Judd at melbourne. finally we would have a player whos actually in the top 2 players in the league.

What would people give up for him?

*Bruce & TJ to Eagles +

exchange our 1st rnd pick No 4 for their current 1st rnd pick.

*Bruce & TJ to Eagles +

exchange our 1st rnd pick No 4 for their current 1st rnd pick.

Sounds fair.

I stopped reading there. You're all blinded my Brocks (and our) shithouse season. Brock McLean is still oozing with leadership qualities and under no circumstances should be traded. That's right, not even for god...

but you might note that this trade includes Judd AND Staker. Staker by himself would be worth a top 10 pick...otherall it balances out. gotta give quality to get quality.

now let's make a huuugggeee assumption. trade week has just started and Judd nominated the demons as his prefered club to play for (ala Akermanis and bulldogs). it is now up to WestCoast and demons to make a deal that is reasonable and fair to both sides...

who would you be willing to trade for Judd.

My possible trade:

1)

Johnstone and pick 4 to WCE (quality midfield replacement and top draft pick)

Judd and pick 40something to MFC

2)

Pick 4, Sylvia and Davey to WCE (high pick, and 2 young quality upncomers)

Judd and pick 40ish to MFC

3)

pick 4, pick 21 and Mclean to WCE (2 good draft picks and Mclean a gun youngster)

Judd and Staker to Melbourne to MFC

oh how id love to see Judd at melbourne. finally we would have a player whos actually in the top 2 players in the league.

What would people give up for him?

I too would love to see judd in the red and blue but what to give WCE is a very difficult desion. Your trades are alright but we lose to much for the one player. My prefered trade would be:

Miller (Young versitile KPP do appeal to some clubs especially clubs without many forwards) and a quality midfielder such as green, bruce travis etc. (My choice would be Green now ok i know he is a hard midfielder who always tries his hardest with lots of leadership qualities but i think judd fills all these and thensome.) and a late draft pick i.e 4th pick

Miller, Green and our 4th Pick (im not sure what it is)

For Judd and one or 2 of there picks (if one then a 2nd pick if two then lower ones)

People have been worrying about Judds injuries but personally (im no doctor but heres my opinon) I think its not OP and after some rest over the pre season he will be fine for 2008

2)

Pick 4, Sylvia and Davey to WCE (high pick, and 2 young quality upncomers)

blinded by the light...

that is trash...

that willl achive nothing but satifiaction knowing we have "judd"

Make no mistake. The MFC should be celebrating for a week if it landed Judd. I know I would. It's not a flag, but arguably the next best thing. And could deliver one. If he wants to come back to Victoria we should leave no stone unturned in getting him. His injury (some floating bone in his groin) will be relieved by a minor operation.

Let's stop being an also ran. An irrelevent club. A minor consideration. Nice.

If he's available, get him.

What would I pay ? Pick 4, Bruce, Frawley (West Coast were very interested last draft).

I stopped reading there. You're all blinded my Brocks (and our) shithouse season. Brock McLean is still oozing with leadership qualities and under no circumstances should be traded. That's right, not even for god...

oozing bad leadership qualities all year.... u urself are blinded...

Miller, Green and our 4th Pick (im not sure what it is)

You're really offering pick 4 and Green. It won't get it done.

I agree Hannabal

LETS BE BOLD

LETS SHOW SOME INITIATIVE FOR ONCE

Lets put pull all stops to get C.Judd to Melbourne

He will have groin surgery in the next fortnight, and he will be as good as gold

Who wouldnt want a fully fit JUDD running around for the MFC? He will be the best player to ever pull on the Red and Blue, and we will be able to watch him and cheer for hiom every week!!

MY TRADE

Demons send Cameron Bruce, Chris Johnson, pick 4 and pick 21 to the Eagles

for Chris Judd and pick 15

*Bruce & TJ to Eagles +

exchange our 1st rnd pick No 4 for their current 1st rnd pick.

Fair

You're really offering pick 4 and Green. It won't get it done.

Not pick 4 our 4th pick so like pick 40 or something i wouldnt give up all that

Not pick 4 our 4th pick so like pick 40 or something i wouldnt give up all that

Then you're stupid and wasting my time.

Fair

Where are you Rhino?

Mad to get Judd at any price and if you think he alone will win a GF think again, do you think a mill a year as reported will solve the problem then you are barking up the wrong tree, not worth it.

Where are you Rhino?

I'd offer Ferguson, Miller, Pettard's busted lung plus pick 86 for Judd, Embley and their second round pick......

That's fair

I agree Hannabal

LETS BE BOLD

LETS SHOW SOME INITIATIVE FOR ONCE

Lets put pull all stops to get C.Judd to Melbourne

He will have groin surgery in the next fortnight, and he will be as good as gold

Who wouldnt want a fully fit JUDD running around for the MFC? He will be the best player to ever pull on the Red and Blue, and we will be able to watch him and cheer for hiom every week!!

MY TRADE

Demons send Cameron Bruce, Chris Johnson, pick 4 and pick 21 to the Eagles

for Chris Judd and pick 15

In the words of Darryl Kerrigan "tell him he's dreamin"!

Mad to get Judd at any price and if you think he alone will win a GF think again, do you think a mill a year as reported will solve the problem then you are barking up the wrong tree, not worth it.

I am pretty sure that no player is worth a million a year........

This is because while he would make us better, the flip side is the cost problems it could cause with the rest of the list.

One man can help win us a Premiership, but he certainly can't do it alone, and for that price he may well have to <_< !!!

oozing bad leadership qualities all year.... u urself are blinded...

No one should be judged on this year, write off...