miller has been good since been pushed forward

should have had the shot though

someone need to make bruce drop the ball closer to his body, he drops it a mile from himself which why he has to really reach out with the kicking foot

19 for petterd

why isnt godfrey banging into goodes shoulder?

he bloody should be

PETTERD GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAALLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL

GOODES deserves 2 weeks for that the dirty [censored]!

miller on hall and godfrey on goodes! Bring on 2008

Godders Bathed him

why didnt godfrey tackle him? instead he tries to bump him and then they get a goal

petterd 20 pos

11 kicks, 9 handballs, 1 goal, stood in front of hall

BRILLIANT! ABSOLUTELTY BRILLIANT!

why isnt godfrey banging into goodes shoulder?

he bloody should be

He was

Godders got into him earlier, and goodes cracked a massive sad at the time. Had to duck a friend out to do nightwork at a supermarket, what did Goodes do that deserves 2 weeks?

MASSIVE ELBOW INTO HIS BACK, he runs straight up to him and does it so he knew what he was doing, intentional, high impact, behind play

sorry about the caps

Some members here will be happy to know Bate is injured. Im not but there are thoes calling his cra* so u guys will be gleaming

im on the positives at the moment

petterd

petterd

petterd

havent been so happy or in love with a player since the ox graced us with his presence

He reminded me aswell of oxes first game

Wouldn't mind having Brett Kirk in my team... 16 kicks and handballs, 7 tackles and 5-0 free kicks for!

Wasn't goodes the recipient of something similar? Oh that's right, Neita crunched him in the back recently.

Oh well, back to the ol drawing board.

I sat through the whole game. Some good things such as beamer and young ricky, but plenty of things to ponder also.

Time to start thinking about next week.

NOW ON TO THE WORLD CUP!!

I was thinking to myself with 2 minutes to go "Gees, first game this season where we sustained no injuries"... trust me to jinx us!

Bate on crutches is a terrible sign. I thought he was much improved today after a couple of ordinary games. He looked comfortable on the wing.

When will this nightmare run of injuries end? Hopefully Green is ready to come straight back in to replace him.

Well what can you say, huge loss on the scoreboard, but apart from the first quarter where we played pathetically, I thought we at least fought out the rest of the game. The real worry for me is the midfield. Can McLean and Jones really be the only 2 effective clearance players we have?

McLean's fitness is just so vital to this side. Not only does he get the ball, he also takes the opposition's best tagger away from TJ. Hopefully he'll be back for the Eagles game, or I'm scared a record losing margin is on the cards.

Godfrey was probably BOG tonight, which is scary thought in itself. He did a great job on Goodes, who was clearly playing hurt in the second half, but the fact that he got stuck into him was just gold to watch. Might cop a week for that sly elbow in the back. Sometimes I just love Simon Godfrey (I feel very dirty for saying that!).

I was thinking to myself with 2 minutes to go "Gees, first game this season where we sustained no injuries"... trust me to jinx us!

Bate on crutches is a terrible sign. I thought he was much improved today after a couple of ordinary games. He looked comfortable on the wing.

When will this nightmare run of injuries end? Hopefully Green is ready to come straight back in to replace him.

Well what can you say, huge loss on the scoreboard, but apart from the first quarter where we played pathetically, I thought we at least fought out the rest of the game. The real worry for me is the midfield. Can McLean and Jones really be the only 2 effective clearance players we have?

McLean's fitness is just so vital to this side. Not only does he get the ball, he also takes the opposition's best tagger away from TJ. Hopefully he'll be back for the Eagles game, or I'm scared a record losing margin is on the cards.

Godfrey was probably BOG tonight, which is scary thought in itself. He did a great job on Goodes, who was clearly playing hurt in the second half, but the fact that he got stuck into him was just gold to watch. Might cop a week for that sly elbow in the back. Sometimes I just love Simon Godfrey (I feel very dirty for saying that!).

Dont feel dirty...share the love

its ok jaded its dirty love

moloney and petterd were our 2 best

miller, godfrey were also very good

Don't under estimate the effect on losing Bartram as well, he gets to job on the better midfielders that frees us Mcdonald to attack the footy at clearances. With Bartram out Mcdonald has play defensive.

THIS IS THE WORST GAME OF FOOTBALL I HAVE EVER SEEN. IN SO MANY YEARS, I HAVE NEVER SEEN A MORE DISGUSTING GAME OF FOOTBALL BY SO CALLED "ATHLETES" THAN I HAVE TONIGHT

BRUCE, JOHNSTONE, YZE, DAVEY, PICKETT....WHERE ARE YOU GUYS???????????????????????????????????????????

I thought Johnno put in and Davey and Yze were not too bad now Bruce is another matter he is NOT interested

I'd say that, quite astonishingly, Pettard was best on ground for Melb.

Disappointed of course with losing our 5th straight game, but there some some positives, as some of you have mentioned like:

* Ricky playing a great debut game

* We tried hard to fight our way back in the game

GOODES deserves 2 weeks for that the dirty [censored]!

he will get at least one, but he might be given a commendation, you don't know with those idiots at the tribunal

Another display of indirect football by Melbourne. Lost count at the number of times Sydney kicked long and direct which resulted in goals. Melbourne need to seriously consider a new game plan, it's clearly obvious after 0-5 that what they are setting out to do is not working. How many more weeks can they continue to do this.

THUMBS UP:

Ricky Pettard...what a sensational debut match. He's picking up where Nathan Jones left off. Well done Ricky.

Aaron Davey...a great game by him, good to see him finding his form slowly. He tried hard.

Cameron Bruce...played all over the place, good running, great game.

Jared Rivers...did a great job, as well as pick up the pieces Carroll and Bell left behind. Well done Jared.

Almost thumbs up: Pickett, White, Lynden Dunn, Brent Maloney.

THUMBS DOWN:

Brad Miller...still not convinced. Had the chance to get Melbourne back into the game...nothing.

Nathan Carroll...fumbling around a little too much, lost composure, although did well on Hall.

Paul Johnson...drop him. He's contributed nothing.

Nathan Brown...needs to be replaced next week with Clint Bizzell.

Travis Johnstone...playing nothing like we all know he can. MIA.

Next week V Port Adelaide at home...We'll manage to scrape approx 15,000 fans into the G...disgraceful. When are those Demons going to break the drought and win a game. It's strangely feeling like the year 1996 all over again...

Another display of indirect football by Melbourne. Lost count at the number of times Sydney kicked long and direct which resulted in goals. Melbourne need to seriously consider a new game plan, it's clearly obvious after 0-5 that what they are setting out to do is not working. How many more weeks can they continue to do this.

THUMBS UP:

Ricky Pettard...what a sensational debut match. He's picking up where Nathan Jones left off. Well done Ricky.

Aaron Davey...a great game by him, good to see him finding his form slowly. He tried hard.

Cameron Bruce...played all over the place, good running, great game.

Jared Rivers...did a great job, as well as pick up the pieces Carroll and Bell left behind. Well done Jared.

Almost thumbs up: Pickett, White, Lynden Dunn, Brent Maloney.

THUMBS DOWN:

Brad Miller...still not convinced. Had the chance to get Melbourne back into the game...nothing.

Nathan Carroll...fumbling around a little too much, lost composure, although did well on Hall.

Paul Johnson...drop him. He's contributed nothing.

Nathan Brown...needs to be replaced next week with Clint Bizzell.

Travis Johnstone...playing nothing like we all know he can. MIA.

Next week V Port Adelaide at home...We'll manage to scrape approx 15,000 fans into the G...disgraceful. When are those Demons going to break the drought and win a game. It's strangely feeling like the year 1996 all over again...

could be the first time Port beat us at MCG