DEES TEAM v CATS

[Scoop Junior 3,513]

I wouldn't mind seeing a bit of spine with the supporters...

Reckon they are all crowing over at the Geelong supporters website. What say we just support the team and scream our heads off. Sure on paper it looks hopeless, but how many times have we seen the understrength team get up? It's not the final straw for me if they don't play Sylvia, or they do play Yze or Danners has a brain fade, what is getting close to a final straw for me is the continious stream of negativity.

Go Dees!

Gee lighten up, get a sense of humour!

We will all be there on Sunday supporting the team because we are passionate supporters.

But surely we can poke a little fun at the team on paper.

No game is impossible to win.

[Jaded No More 68,974]

Gee lighten up, get a sense of humour!

Exactly.

'Melbourne Supporting for Dummies', Chapter 1- Get a sense of humour <_<

[Nicho 1]

Demons are in for a tough time but i'm now looking forward to the next 6 weeks for another reason.. We have a very tough run and could easily be 8-0 if we don't play some good Footy soon but i hope we try some new stuff...

Play Paul Johnson as a permanent forward and give Brad miller a run at full-forward. Get rid of muppets like Godfrey, Brown and Wheatley, give the Show Biz his chance which he deserves. Give our new kids a run like Garland and Pettard as there is no point playing morons like Godfrey when we can get some early games into these young ones...Every other team is doing it even the strong ones like Sydney and West Coast as it seems to have great benefits....

This is a time where Neale Daniher can show us some creativity and problem solving because we already know the space cadet cant coach to save himself.

Colin Sylvia is still carrying some soreness and like Pickett due back Round 4.

What do you guys think?

Quick question- Paul Johnson is a better player than the big Russian Jamar so why this year are we still persisting with Jamar?

FF Johnson Miller Davey

HF Yze Bate Green

C Mcdonald Moloney Bruce

HB Bizzell Holland Ward

FB Bell Carroll Whelan

R White Johnstone Jones

INT Pettard C johnson Jamar Brown

[Yze_Magic 3]

You picked the best lineup from the 25 man squad

if that team wins i will do cartwheels

[H.B.K 0]

why the hell wasnt any of Garland, Newton or Sylvia picked is what I wanna know

[Guest dee'viator]

It maybe like this

Backs:................ M.Whelan,,, N.Carroll,,,,,,, B.Holland

Half backs: ........ C.Bizzell,,,,,, R.Ferguson,, D.Bell

Centreline:......... B.Moloney,,,C.Bruce,,,,,,,,, D.Ward

Half forwards: ....B.Green,,,,,, B.Miller,,,,,,,,,, A.Davey

Forwards:...........M.Bate,,,,,,,, P.Johnson,,,,, A.Yze

Followers: J.White, N.Jones, T.Johnstone

I/C From: M.Jamar, J.McDonald, S.Godfrey, N.Brown, ,,,,, R.Petterd,

OUTS: P.Wheatley, C.Johnson,

INJ: Neitz, Robbo,

Seniors

Sandringham

Goal Kickers: N. Sautner 7, C. Sylvia 3, S. Valenti, C. Garland, A. Yze 2, P. Johnson, M. Newton, P. Summers, B. Pickett, M. Ferguson, R. Crowe, B. Holland.

Best Players: P. Summers, R. Ferguson, C. Sylvia, S. Valenti, N. Sautner, A. Yze

I don't want to see PJ playing just in the goal square, I want him to lead out & play between 40Mtrs to 70Mtrs dragging Scarlett out with him. PJ is quite good when the ball has hit the ground, where he can gather, run & kick or feed off to a team mate running past. The forward space around the goal square is where we want Yze & Davey to use their tricks with Miller close by assisting with some heavy work & defending hard, locking the ball in.

If we can put maximum pressure on the cats defence by playing man on man when their trying to exit their full backline with PJ & our working ruckman on opposite sides of CHB, we could cause them some trouble. But we must keep our full forward line OPEN deep.

[DoubleDees 1]

why the hell wasnt any of Garland, Newton or Sylvia picked is what I wanna know

Sylvia is injured..

The other 2 combined have kicked about 8 goals for Sandringham and are not good enough yet.

[Bring-Back-Powell 14,939]

Anyone want to guess the final 22 before its released tonight.

In - Holland, Bizzell, Yze, P Johnson

Out - Robbo (inj), Neitz (inj), Rivers (inj), C Johnson

EMERG - C Johnson, Petterd, Ferguson

INS:

Holland's confirmed in the 22 to heighten our defence.

Bizzell should come in to add some versaltility forward or back

Yze should come in to add some scoring power (if he's still capable at this level)

I had trouble tossing up between P Johnson (a foward option) or Ferguson to add an option in defence. Went with PJ as every man and his dog around here wants him in the side.

OUTS:

Robbo, Neitz and Rivers are confirmed out.

Toss up between CJ and Brown. Went with CJ as he hasn't shown he's capable at AFL level as yet (apart from NAB Cup/regional games) and only averaging 10 possessions. At least with Brown, you can be guranteed 20-25 possessions but hope to god he uses the pill properly.

Would love to see Pettard debut this Sunday. Saw the kid V Geelong at Skilled (Mar 17th) and showed he'll be a class act in the future (albeit only had 30% game time). Me thinks he's not ready though.

[Guest dee'viator]

Anyone want to guess the final 22 before its released tonight.

In - Holland, Bizzell, Yze, P Johnson

Out - Robbo (inj), Neitz (inj), Rivers (inj), C Johnson

EMERG - C Johnson, Petterd, Ferguson

INS:

Holland's confirmed in the 22 to heighten our defence.

Bizzell should come in to add some versaltility forward or back

Yze should come in to add some scoring power (if he's still capable at this level)

I had trouble tossing up between P Johnson (a foward option) or Ferguson to add an option in defence. Went with PJ as every man and his dog around here wants him in the side.

OUTS:

Robbo, Neitz and Rivers are confirmed out.

Toss up between CJ and Brown. Went with CJ as he hasn't shown he's capable at AFL level as yet (apart from NAB Cup/regional games) and only averaging 10 possessions. At least with Brown, you can be guranteed 20-25 possessions but hope to god he uses the pill properly.

Would love to see Pettard debut this Sunday. Saw the kid V Geelong at Skilled (Mar 17th) and showed he'll be a class act in the future (albeit only had 30% game time). Me thinks he's not ready though.

In - Holland, Bizzell, Yze, P Johnson,

Out - Robbo, Neitz, Rivers, C Johnson, Wheatley (ps, I have feeling Pettard's coming in for someoneas well)

Yze for Robbo

P Johnson for Neitz

Holland for Rivers ( to wrestle with the furry cat)

Bizzell for Wheatley - (to setup the plays.)

either Brown or Pettard for C Johnson. (to provide some run & carry)

Holland's confirmed in the 22 to heighten our defence.

Bizzell should come in to add some versaltility forward or back.

Yze should come in to add some scoring power (if he's still capable at this level)

PJ has to come in to try & stretch their defensive talls as Tom Harley is out injured, hopefully he'll take Scarlett away from goal.

[Jaded No More 68,974]

If CJ gets dropped, and I wasn't such a sucker for this football club, I'd boycott the game!

With an already depleted forward line, this could be his chance to shine. He got limited game time last week, most of which was spent down back (not his natural position IMO). What the hell are we doing if we drop an unproven 22 year old for an over the hill 30 year old?!

[demon_fanatic 4]

Yeh i think Cj just needs to be played as either a full time winger of full time forward... i think he would do great one out he just needs to be given more than 2 weeks in the team let the guy settle.

dont worry come 5pm today i am sure he would of been dropped for some "dead wood"... frustrating but if i see CJ and Pettard out i will be very very angry...

[Madness 44]

If CJ gets dropped I'll be rampant because I think he has awesome potential and needs to keep getting gametime in the 1sts... That and he's in my dreamteam!

[Bring-Back-Powell 14,939]

If CJ gets dropped, and I wasn't such a sucker for this football club, I'd boycott the game!

With an already depleted forward line, this could be his chance to shine. He got limited game time last week, most of which was spent down back (not his natural position IMO). What the hell are we doing if we drop an unproven 22 year old for an over the hill 30 year old?!

Fair call. Don't have any problems giving him a couple of more games...but you have to draw the line somewhere.

Is it just me, or does CJ always play in losing sides. I think the St.Kilda, Collingwood, Essendon and Brisbane games of last year where the only wins he's played in.

[Gouga 570]

I actually disagree. I think CJ needs a week at Sandy. He needs to get some game time and plenty of touches.

With Brown, Godfrey, Ward and Wheatley in the seniors he will get his place straight back and will be better for his run in the magoos.

[Jaded No More 68,974]

I actually disagree. I think CJ needs a week at Sandy. He needs to get some game time and plenty of touches.

So do Davey, Bartram and TJ going on form, but this is not the time to be dropping class players with above-average disposal. Not when we're already missing McLean, Rivers, Bartram, Neita, Robbo, Pickett, Sylvia and Dunn.

[Gouga 570]

Does that mean Chris Johnson is a class player Jaded?

I wouldn't think so. Hopefully one day. Don't forget some of these blokes are still developing.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Sylvia is injured..

The other 2 combined have kicked about 8 goals for Sandringham and are not good enough yet.

Correct Brocky.

[Dappa Dan 2,188]

The other 2 combined have kicked about 8 goals for Sandringham and are not good enough yet.

Correct Brocky.

Well now, that's never stopped some of the other players who are still getting games has it? Some of them don't even have futures. I doubt there's 30 listed AFL players that COULDN'T get a game for the 16th placed dees at the moment, and if Newton is one of them, I'm stunned. Kicked 8 goals for Sandy? Not true, and besides, that doesn't accurately describe why the players are perceived as "not good enough" yet. At least not Newton.

But again, it's just a difference of opinion. Me and a few others vs Rhino, MFC footy department and some others. What difference does it make? Come Sunday night we may find out something new, or we may find out what we all have been hypothesising for months...

Bring it on.

[9. David Neitz 0]

If CJ gets dropped I'll be rampant because I think he has awesome potential and needs to keep getting gametime in the 1sts... That and he's in my dreamteam!

Chris Johnson has been awful the last 2 weeks, lucky to be in the team

[kieranbj 111]

Kicked 8 goals for Sandy? Not true

Don’t forget the distinction between sandy res and seniors. I would be surprised if Newts has kicked many more then 8 senior goals.

A little part of me did want to see Newton picked because i have seen a lot of him and think he is a real talent, the man to eventually take over from Neita. However now is not the right time. As someone else said previously Newton needs to make his debut with Neita or at least Robbo there beside him.

As for this week our best chance of winning comes from a smallish forward line with the presence of the resting ruckman. If we can get a couple of bags of 3 from say two of the likes of green, yze, bruce, tj, davey or bate and 3 or 4 between the ruckmen we are on the way to a decent score.

I think our forward line will adept better then most believe. For me it is the Rivers-less backline that has me most worried. Holland will do a job and hopefully carroll and whelan can return to form but the cats forward line is looking tremendously multi-dimensional. I could see up to six players with realistic chances of snatching a bag of 5 this weekend.

[Rivers Run Red 187]

If delivery into the forward line is going to be critical we are absolutely screwed!

Oh Jeeeez we are in a shed load of trouble.

Seeming as we are ranked 15th for inside 50's, now we need not only quantity but quality...

Good luck boys.

[DemonTux 97]

Fergy for FF (no worrys about decision making then...)

while im thinking about it... we have lost some calss but the replacements will be fearless and try all day... almost enough to make me think we have a 30% chance of winning.

[Madness 44]

MELBOURNEfc has made four changes to its team to face Geelong at the MCG on Sunday afternoon.

Into the team come Ryan Ferguson and Paul Johnson for their first games of 2007 along with reliable defender Ben Holland and veteran Adem Yze.

Missing from the team will be Chris Johnson and Jared Rivers, who pulled up sore with a hamstring complaint. They will be joined on the sidelines by Melbourne’s lengthy list of casualties, David Neitz (knee – 3-4 weeks), Russell Robertson (knee – 6 weeks), McLean (foot – 5 weeks) and Clint Bartram (knee – TBA).

Melbourne Team

Backs:B.Holland, N.Carroll, M.Whelan

Half backs: D.Ward, P.Wheatley, D.Bell

Centreline: B.Moloney, J.McDonald, B.Green

Half forwards: C.Bruce, B.Miller, M.Bate

Forwards: S.Godfrey, M.Jamar, A.Davey

Followers: J.White, N.Jones, T.Johnstone

I/C: N.Brown, P.Johnson, R.Ferguson, A.Yze

[Jaded No More 68,974]

Missing from the team will be Chris Johnson

ARGH! I can't believe they dropped CJ. Talk about scapegoat!

So that means...

Out: Neita, Robbo, Rivers, CJ

In: PJ, Ferguson, Holland, Yze

Slow, immobile forward line here we come!

[Madness 44]

I'm confused, the way that worded that saying that they will join the causality list, makes it sound like hes injured not omitted.