6- N Jones

5- Jetta

4- Dunn

3- Gawn ... for the header knockout

2- Tyson

1- Vince

lots of MINUS votes

People putting Viney in their best!?!?!? You have to be kidding. A player has to do more than get to a contest, get beaten to the ball, look angry, tackle hard and run hard at the next opposition player. He had no effect on the game whatsoever.

Is it just me or has Viney had an ordinary second season?

He was good in early season games against Adelaide and Richmond but I can't recall too many good performances since.

Is it just me or has Viney had an ordinary second season?

He was good in early season games against Adelaide and Richmond but I can't recall too many good performances since.

2nd half of the season, was good early but seems to have dropped off. He is a 2nd year player and shouldn't be expected to carry the load but with a lot of the senior players disappointing then it exposes him more.

I defy anyone to come up with six good players.

Baldy.

Cross=earnt every cent.

Treloar=gun

Kelly=future gun

WHE=future freak

Shiel=gun

6. N Jones (by a street)

5. Tyson (then another street)

4. Jetta

3. Gawn

2. Michie

1. Dunn

Really, only the first four deserve votes. Dunn gets his for his first half in the backline. I'm absolutely convinced he's a defender, not a forward. We looked worse without him in the back half and no better with him up forward (although that's not entirely his fault given the delivery into the forward 50).

And McDonald gets plaudits for effort but somehow he managed to expose and exaggerate all his weaknesses in the one game.