Who will have the biggest impact in their first 2 years of AFL?

I think we should take Taylor.

What about Kelly?

What about trading pick 2?
What about not making this thread

Who will have the biggest impact in their first 2 years of AFL?

I think we should take Taylor.

Good player but too short, will he be Harvey, Betts or Callinan. Harvey's a win, Betts loss on pick 2, Callinan a bust.

Who will be the better player at the end of their career, my money would be on Aish by a fair way.

What about Kelly?

What about trading pick 2?

What about not making this thread

Kelly would just runs rings around both players.

Josh Kelly is the best player in the draft and he is by a fair space IMO.

Kelly would just runs rings around both players.

Josh Kelly is the best player in the draft and he is by a fair space IMO.

If Josh could kick further than 45 metres, I might agree with you.

I think Taylor is the same height as Shane Crawford (174cm). Prestia does OK too despite being 175cm.

I really like Taylor. He just has footy smarts and is so composed with the ball. He runs to the right spots and is clean under pressure. I know his height will knock him down a rung, or two, but I reckon he'll become an A-grade mid in time.

Edited October 13, 201312 yr by Ben-Hur

Who will have the biggest impact in their first 2 years of AFL?

I think we should take Taylor.

Your question has absolutely nothing to do with who we should select in the draft, and if you don't understand that you're beyond help.