Palmer like Scully, is apparently on the move, so I guess there's not much incentive; how's Tom going?

Ridiculous argument.

Palmer was terrible last year when there was no way he could know where he was going, if he's going at all.

for a top 5 team

This doesn't help your argument.

This doesn't help your argument.

I think Cook not making it in to the best at casey reserves does.

Didn't Palmer have a knee reco in his second year, that may have impeded his progress a bit, don't you think?

Didn't Palmer have a knee reco in his second year, that may have impeded his progress a bit, don't you think?

Oh well. Point is, he was everyone's talking point in 2008, and now no one could care less about him, whether he's going to GWS or not.

Daniel Rich falls into the exact same category, so I'm not too fussed whether Palmer's knee has held him back a lot or not at all.

I think Cook not making it in to the best at casey reserves does.

Didn't Palmer have a knee reco in his second year, that may have impeded his progress a bit, don't you think?

May have.

I'm not concerned about Cook at all.

Have you seen him play? He shows a lot of promise.

Remember, back in reserves, the delivery he receives is further reduced.

Last week they won in a canter, not sure about yesterday, but not being in the best players in a heavily lop-sided contest doesn't say much.

Thanks folks --- game's over, now for POST MATCH DISCUSSION