Dees Trade Week - Tim Harrington

[Disco Demons 92]

Blease was recruited as a dashing wingman, I don't think he has played on the half back flank?

The only players on our list who who can play half back flank & have elite kicking skills is Grimes & Strauss... Strauss has played 2 games. Whilst we have depth in tall to medium size defenders who can hold their own in a marking contest, we don't have any real depth in regards to backmen with pace & elite disposal. We still rely on Davey to distribute the ball far too much out of our backline.

i hear what your saying....personally i'm happy to have davey continue playing his role across half back...when grimes goes into the midfield eventually he will play a similar role. and strauss to follow.

if you draft a hbf...who you going to drop from the back six? bartram....assuming grimes to go into the midfield eventually..and strauss to take grimes spot.

[rpfc 28,407]

Grimes's kicking isn't consistent.He made many mistakes kicking out and in field play this year.Strauss- if good enough is a better kick-Gilbee type.

He's a good kick.

That is the way I see it.

And it isn't just because Freak sees it the other way.

Well, not entirely...

[Roost It 1,434]

I have usually supported your posts- however I think this is a little over the top- it is always hard in recruiting- you never know how any player will go until tested against the ultimate best.And look at the above players you have outlined- all showed ability - maybe Weetra being the exception- however didn't make an elite player. There is and will always be these types on all lists- we cannot all be elite players.Lastly,I thought Kowal was a pretty good footballer -played over 100 games and was a midget at 173 cms tall. Darren Kowal

Last played for Melbourne Demons in 1999

Games: 105 Born: June 18, 1972

Playing Height: 173cm Playing Weight: 74kg

We had the chance to swap Kowal for David Wirrapunda and Balme said no, I never forgave him. Kowal was ordinary

[Bonkers 994]

i hear what your saying....personally i'm happy to have davey continue playing his role across half back...when grimes goes into the midfield eventually he will play a similar role. and strauss to follow.

if you draft a hbf...who you going to drop from the back six? bartram....assuming grimes to go into the midfield eventually..and strauss to take grimes spot.

Bartram is a tagger essentially, his spot is the side is not solid & he is not a HBF. We don't even know if Strauss will develop so we can hardly say he is going to take Grimes place. We have 2-3 players in depth to cover every other position/role in the team apart from the HBF and KPF. In todays football the HBF at times is the most important in the team, they have the ability to create play, break defensive zones & lines, create the spare man in defence or midfield & join in the midfield rotations. If we draft players with more ability in this part of the team hypothetically it will free up players like Grimes & Davey to influence the game in the forward half more, we will become a better scoring side & make us a harder team to shut down.

[Roost It 1,434]

With regard to what we need. The fact we're chasing Hale sums it up. If Tom Lynch is available at 12 he's ours.

[rpfc 28,407]

We had the chance to swap Kowal for David Wirrapunda and Balme said no, I never forgave him. Kowal was ordinary

Kowal's bird didn't want to go to Perth.

And then a couple years later she got a job there I believe.

[Bonkers 994]

With regard to what we need. The fact we're chasing Hale sums it up. If Tom Lynch is available at 12 he's ours.

Only problem is that he will take time to develop. A 4 year project similar to Watts.

[Roost It 1,434]

Kowal's bird didn't want to go to Perth.

And then a couple years later she got a job there I believe.

What's that got to do with it, it was upto the club not Kowal

[dee-luded 2,959]

Bartram is a tagger essentially, his spot is the side is not solid & he is not a HBF. We don't even know if Strauss will develop so we can hardly say he is going to take Grimes place. We have 2-3 players in depth to cover every other position/role in the team apart from the HBF and KPF. In todays football the HBF at times is the most important in the team, they have the ability to create play, break defensive zones & lines, create the spare man in defence or midfield & join in the midfield rotations. If we draft players with more ability in this part of the team hypothetically it will free up players like Grimes & Davey to influence the game in the forward half more, we will become a better scoring side & make us a harder team to shut down.

I'm with you 'Bonkers'. I think It's the most skilled part of the ground.

The half backline, probably the most important for winning the game, over the whole 4 Qtrs. Same as Mid zone but more vision needed & disposal.

See the Blues right now, panicking & chopping their's up. They know it's not up to scratch.

[Fan in the outer 0]

We had the chance to swap Kowal for David Wirrapunda and Balme said no, I never forgave him. Kowal was ordinary

I remember being quite annoyed that they let that opportunity go. We've always hung on to serviceable players too long and not traded them when we could of. I thought they should have tried to offload Darren Bennett instead of letting that op go by and for him to go on and become an NFL punter for no compensation. So I'm all for trading players who aren't going to help us win a premiership.

[e25 5]

Only problem is that he will take time to develop. A 4 year project similar to Watts.

No, that's not a problem. That's expected and it would mean he is peaking while our window is open. Extending our window, even.

No, the problem is that he won't be left by pick 12.

[Steamin Demon 392]

No, that's not a problem. That's expected and it would mean he is peaking while our window is open. Extending our window, even.

No, the problem is that he won't be left by pick 12.

What makes you so sure, Crystal ball getting a fair work out ?

[rpfc 28,407]

What's that got to do with it, it was upto the club not Kowal

We agreed a trade but Darren wouldn't go because his gf didn't want to go to Perth.

It happens.